Search results for

Lawyers

44

Dr. Dorothee Altenburg represents clients in all aspects of intellectual property law. She is particularly experienced in the area of trademark law. Operating in Germany as well as internationally, Dr. Altenburg devises legal strategies to establish and defend trademarks, design rights, and patents. She represents clients before the relevant authorities in Germany, in the European Union, and in WIPO proceedings. She conducts trademark registrations worldwide. She has substantial experience in drafting licensing agreements. She is acquainted with the litigation issues that arise in the environs of intellectual property and (unfair) competition law. She represents clients before customs authorities counterfeiting cases. She also coordinates EU-wide customs seizure proceedings against counterfeit products.

Dr. Altenburg further represents publishers, media companies, and artists in matters to do with copyright, publishing law, and personality rights. 

Nikolaus Bertermann has been a lawyer for a Europe-wide leading internet service provider for ten years and can therefore rely on in-depth technical expertise, a sound knowledge of the IT industry, and many years of experience as a company lawyer.

He provides comprehensive advice on all forms of classic and agile software creation and IT project contracts, the use and adaptation of open source software, and cloud computing within and outside the EU.

Mr. Bertermann conducts data protection audits, advises companies on the legally compliant design of data processing procedures within and outside corporate structures, and accompanies clients in projects to implement the requirements of the EU General Data Protection Regulation. He commented on the central provisions of the GDPR for publishing house C.H.Beck.

Eva Bonacker advises German and international clients on diverse matters of competition, M&A, corporate and general commercial law, with a special focus on European and German antitrust and competition law.

Eva Bonacker has advised clients from various industries including media, IT and software, e-commerce, publishing, information and business intelligence, energy, climate technology, and consumer goods.

Dr. Mathias Pajunk advises on all issues of public commercial law. The main focus of his work lies on advising public authorities on the award of public contracts and service concessions. This includes the monitoring of awards at all stages, including the drafting of contracts. At the same time, Dr. Mathias Pajunk represents both public authorities and bidders in the context of review proceedings. His other fields of activity include dealing with complex issues in the areas of state aid and antitrust law.

Dr. Brock specializes in IP law (trademarks, patents, designs, copyright law, etc.), unfair competition law (including advertising law), IT law, data protection law as well as distribution and contract law.

He advises comprehensively on IP matters, including the filing of national and international intellectual property rights as well as licensing and enforcement in disputes in and out of court. He further advises on innovation and know-how protection (including trade secrets), on cross-border research and development projects, on employees’ inventions law, and on standard essential patents (SEP). Furthermore, his advice includes the development of brand-based labeling and quality seal systems.

While his client base covers a wide selection of industries (for instance health care & life sciences, information technology and consumer goods), he focuses on technology-driven and innovative companies, ranging from start-ups to mid-sized companies to globally operating corporations.

Dr. Oliver M. Bühr has been advising on IT matters for many years. This includes software, hardware, projects, and outsourcing. He frequently supports his clients in all matters relating to data protection, especially in the implementation of the GDPR. He also has extensive experience in e-business and advises companies on designing their offerings on the internet. Innovative topics such as cloud computing or the advising of FinTechs are also a key part of his work. Many of the projects on which he advises have an international dimension, and he works closely with lawyers from foreign legal systems.

As a notary, he works particularly in the areas of property law, corporate law, and inheritance law.

Markus von Fuchs advises in intellectual property law, in particular in competition, patent, and trademark law as well as on the protection of know-how. He advises companies on protecting and commercially exploiting intellectual property, for example through licensing, sales, R&D, and cooperation agreements. He also focuses on the judicial and extrajudicial defense of intellectual property rights in interim injunction and principal proceedings. He further advises on border seizing procedures, initiates and advises on criminal measures relating to product and brand piracy, and on the infringement of business and business secrets. Markus von Fuchs also advises many companies on developing and introducing new technologies and business models. He has particular expertise in the optical and medical technology sectors.

Christoph Haesner’s work comprises the entire range of media law, copyright law, and entertainment law. He advises clients in the fields of film and TV, and in sales and licensing on legal issues at all stages of development, production, distribution, and evaluation of audiovisual productions, both nationally and internationally.

His work focuses on all matters pertaining to movie financing, not only for purely national projects, but also for those with major international connections.

He also advises on transactions (M&A) in the media sector. Christoph Haesner regularly supports companies throughout the transaction phase and advises on all matters arising from M&A transactions, under corporate law, contract law, copyright law, and media law.

Dr. Johann Heyde provides comprehensive legal advisory throughout media and entertainment law, in which film and television compose a main focus of his practice. Mr. Heyde advises on all aspects of national and international film and TV productions from film financing and subsidization, right clearance particularly in terms of copyright and privacy law, as well as licensing and exploitation of such productions.

Moreover, Dr. Johann Heyde’s advisory work spans all levels of digital commerce and business with a particular emphasis on improving internet portals, online services and other digital media (including on- demand platforms) and counseling on all relevant legal issues in e-commerce, some of which include terms and conditions, consumer protection, advertising and competition law, licensing and the dissemination of all forms of content over the internet.

Dr. Johann Heyde’s expertise includes his command of music law and especially collecting societies law in particular with respect to digital media.

Dr. Magnus Hirsch advises both German and international clients on a wide variety of matters which fall within the area of trademarks, designs, copyrights, patents, and unfair competition – in both preventative and contentious situations.

He also has more than 25 years of intellectual property litigation experience, having worked on numerous litigation matters regarding all kinds of IP issues and has appeared in many Federal District Courts, as well as Courts of Appeal, throughout Germany, and has represented several clients in proceedings up to the Federal Court of Justice.

In particular, his specialization comprises portfolio management as well as enforcing clients’ rights against counterfeiters, parallel importers and domain name pirates, both through court proceedings, as well as international dispute systems. Mr. Hirsch also represents clients before the German Patent and Trademark Office and the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) registering or opposing German national trademarks and Community Trade Marks, respectively. He also has significant experience in drafting IP-related agreements, such as trademark license agreements, priority agreements and agreements with publicity agencies.

A further focus lies in the field of trademark and competition infringements on the Internet, in particular in the conduct of litigation in and out of court, also in connection with Internet domains, as well as the litigation of patent infringements.

Dr. Magnus Hirsch spent several months practicing at the Hong Kong office of an international law firm where he focused on Asian IP law, especially the enforcement of intellectual property rights in and out of court and the prosecution of product piracy and trademark counterfeiting in Southeast Asia.

Dr. Oliver Hornung advises national and international IT service providers and users in the legal structuring and negotiation of IT, project, and outsourcing contracts, as well as in matters of copyright and licensing. He is also regularly involved in distressed projects (dispute management) and advises clients in conciliation and arbitration proceedings and, where necessary, in litigation.

The regulatory environment for the use of data and corresponding technologies is complex and new legal acts are constantly being added by the European Commission. In this dynamic environment, Dr. Oliver Hornung advises his clients on all legal issues, in particular with a focus on AI compliance, Data Act, NIS-2, cyber security, cloud computing and data law.

Another focus of his legal advice is data protection with a focus on digital health and the EU's Digital Decade. If necessary, Dr. Oliver Hornung and his team defend the rights of his clients before supervisory authorities or in court.

Finally, Dr. Oliver Hornung advises start-ups on all questions relating to IT law and data protection law. In addition to his extensive practical work, Dr. Oliver Hornung is also a frequently requested lecturer in IT law and data protection law.

Klaus Jankowski advises on complex investment projects and company settlements, with a focus on public building and planning law.

For several years, he has also been advising the public sector on legislative projects and sensitive infrastructure projects.

He plays a leading role in the international network of lawyers First Law International and has excellent contacts to law firms worldwide.

Dr. Bernd Joch advises on corporate restructuring in employment law and corporate law, conducts balancing of interests and social plan negotiations, and represents his clients in arbitration proceedings.

He has many years of experience in advising companies, executive board members, general managers, and employees, in particular also in the field of dismissal protection matters.

In the area of commercial law, he advises and represents companies, in particular, in the areas pertaining to agencies and representatives.

René M. Kieselmann specializes in EU public procurement law and associated legal fields. Among others he is a member of SKW Schwarz’s IT & Digital Business and Life Sciences & Health Practice Group and has wide-ranging technical expertise in various areas. In addition to IT law, he advises on state aid law, subsidy law/grant law, and on rescue services and civil protection, i.e. the prevention of health hazards. Jointly with his team he is designing complex public procurement projects. René Kieselmann ensures adequate communication between bidders and clients, constructively conducting negotiations. SKW Schwarz advises on major bidding projects, including in the housing, in healthcare/pharmaceuticals and IT/banking sectors. He is also familiar with the structures of rescue services, civil protection, and disaster control as well as the regulatory context (SGB). Here he constructively designs award procedures on a long-term basis (“planning model”). In this connection, he also deals with issues of medical law ranging from emergency physicians to paramedics. While he is not litigating in court or before the Public Procurement Tribunal frequently, he has nevertheless gained considerable forensic experience since 2009, including at the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Norbert Klingner specializes in national and international movie/TV and advertising film production, financing, insurance, and distribution. He represents well-known producers, distributors, global distributors, and movie financing entities. His expertise ranges from negotiating and drafting contracts from the beginning of the material development to all matters related to production and financing up to the strategically correct exploitation and licensing. A selection of the film productions in which Mr. Klingner was involved can be found on the Internet Movie Database IMDb.

Margret Knitter is a partner at SKW Schwarz and a Certified Specialist in Intellectual Property Law. She has more than 25 years of experience advising and representing German and international clients on intellectual property matters, with a particular focus on patent, trademark, design and unfair competition law.

A key focus of her practice is IP litigation and enforcement. She represents clients in patent infringement proceedings before the German civil courts and the Unified Patent Court (UPC). She also handles complex trademark, design and unfair competition disputes and advises on cross-border IP litigation.

In trademark and design law, she advises companies on developing, managing and enforcing their IP portfolios internationally.

Another core area of her practice is unfair competition and advertising law, particularly in relation to digital business models, social media, influencer marketing, artificial intelligence and environmental advertising claims (green claims). She also has extensive experience advising on product labelling and regulatory compliance.

Margret Knitter heads the Medical Cannabis Focus Group at SKW Schwarz. She advises companies in the cannabis industry on advertising, distribution, regulatory compliance and market access.

Her approach combines extensive litigation experience with strategic thinking and commercial awareness. She delivers pragmatic, business-oriented solutions to complex domestic and cross-border legal challenges.

Dr. Olaf Kreißl is a notary and lawyer specialising in real estate, corporate and inheritance law. He provides support in real estate transactions, property development projects, land and residential property purchase agreements, corporate transactions (M&A) and all corporate law matters (corporate housekeeping, capital increases, conversion and restructuring measures, etc.). In the area of asset management and succession planning or anticipated succession, he drafts and certifies gifts, wills, marriage contracts, divorce agreements, and powers of attorney for precautionary and special purposes.

He also has many years of legal expertise in the field of real estate management and private construction and architectural law.  The focus here is also on advising on legal issues in connection with the management of real estate (commercial leasing, asset management, etc.), the realisation of construction projects and the drafting and negotiation of the corresponding real estate-specific contracts. 

Stefan Kridlo regularly advises national and international companies on all material issues of business law, commercial law, and corporate law, in particular also on corporate acquisitions.

The main focus of his many years of work is the support of real estate investors pertaining to real estate transactions and real estate portfolios, their structuring and administration. Stefan Kridlo worked as a notary until April 2025 in the areas of corporate law, real estate law and inheritance law. He also works as an executor.

Sabine Kröger is a Certified Expert for Commercial and Corporate Law as well as for Banking and Capital Markets Law and advises and represents national and international companies, executives and shareholders comprehensively in the field of corporate law and banking law.

As an experienced litigator, she also comprehensively represents her clients in court (corporate litigation / banking litigation).

Ms. Kröger's activities focus in particular on:

  • advising and representing mid-sized enterprises (SMEs) or their managing directors or shareholders in shareholder disputes and internal company disputes;
  • the assumption of committee representation for shareholders;
  • advising and representing financial investors and credit institutions in the field of credit law and collateral security law and in defending claims of clients/investors, including the representation in mass claim proceedings.

Eberhard Kromer’s traditional focus in media law is entertainment and music. He counsels artists, publishers, labels, internet service providers, managements, as well as tour promoters. He has been active and well-versed in digital commerce issues since the inception of the internet. Eberhard’s practice is constantly affected by rapidly changing e-commerce models, social media platforms and ongoing digitization (Web 4.0, Internet of Things).

Dr. Kromer’s many years of experience as General Counsel and VP Business Affairs for a global media corporation give him the insight to recognize a corporation’s operational strengths and weaknesses. This enables him to find the best solution together with and for the client.

Franziska Ladiges advises clients on all questions of IT and data protection law. Thanks to secondments and many years of experience, she has in-depth knowledge of data protection. In this area, she supports companies (from small businesses to listed companies) from various industries with the implementation of data protection compliance. In addition, she advises on various individual data protection issues, including order processing, data subject rights and international data transfer. Finally, she regularly carries out data protection quick checks for companies on site.

In addition, Franziska Ladiges has experience in drafting contracts regulating the creation, use or transfer of software. She also drafts and reviews general terms and conditions (both purchasing and sales and internet platforms) and advises on the development of online shops and internet platforms. She often represents her clients before state courts in contract disputes or data protection matters.

In the area of private clients, Christoph Meyer has special expertise in establishing and managing family foundations, the creation of succession rules for medium-sized companies and high-net-worth individuals, as well as in all matters pertaining to family law, with a focus on more complex asset situations. The drafting of wills, powers of attorney, and marriage contracts also play an important role, with a considerable proportion of cases having international relevance. Should amicable solutions not be achievable, Mr. Meyer advises the clients, with careful strategic and tactical planning, but also with the required readiness to resolve disputes, through possible legal proceedings before civil and financial courts.

Dr. Ulrich Muth advises companies, in particular banks and financial service providers.

In particular, he specializes in consulting for creditors of loan claims secured by real estate, in the monitoring of credit and reorganization negotiations, in the prevention of damage claims on account of alleged breaches of the duty of disclosure and consultation as well as in the enforcement of creditor interests in the event of the insolvency of the debtor. Based on many years of experience of proceedings in the fields of banking, commercial and company law, as well as in disputes involving competition law, Dr. Muth works together with the clients to develop economic solutions for avoiding legal disputes as well as efficient trial strategies.

Dr. Matthias Nordmann advises international groups, mid cap companies, investors and entrepreneurs on company, commercial and corporate law in particular on structuring and mergers & acquisitions. He has a special focus on transactions in IP/IT driven industries as well as real estate.

Dr. Orthwein was admitted to the bar in 2003 and became a partner at SKW Schwarz in 2011. He received his Master of Laws (LL.M.) in American Law from Boston University (USA) in 2000 and his doctorate from the University Muenster in 2003 with a topic in telecommunications law.

He advises his clients in all areas of IT law, in particular cloud and software contract law using new agile software developing and contract methods, the commercial use of data and artificial intelligence (AI) as well as digital transformation projects. Together with his clients, he develops and brings to life new digital platforms and business models. He is an experienced expert in national and international data protection law issues in particular with regard to the use of cloud services.

The Lexology Index Germany 2025 lists him as a “world's leading practitioner” in the data category. In 2025, Handelsblatt / Best Lawyers again recommends him as a lawyer in the categories “IT law” and “data protection law.” He is once again listed in the JUVE Handbook 2025 as a “frequently recommended lawyer” for IT and data protection law.

Dr. Orthwein is a lecturer for IT and data protection law in applied AI at the Technical University of Rosenheim.

Dr. Orthwein is member of the German Society for Law and Informatics, the International Association of Privacy Professionals, the German Outsourcing Association and the German-American Lawyers Association. He is Senior Vice Chairman of the Technology Law Committee of the International Bar Association.

Dr. Andreas Peschel-Mehner has provided legal counsel to all forms of digital business since the inception of the world wide web. His advisory spans start-ups, multi-channel offerings and international internet companies and focuses on all applicable legal fields with a particular emphasis on data protection and usage, terms and conditions, consumer protection, compliance, advertising, gaming and competition law, among numerous others. Dr. Andreas Peschel-Mehner also commands broad expertise in media and entertainment law, in particular issues touching on the film and television industry and those related to media production finance and the global exploitation thereof, with digital media advisory on changes to utilization models, revenue streams and video on demand platforms composing a significant part of his counsel. 

An excerpt of the projects Dr. Andreas Peschel-Mehner has accompanied can be found on the Internet Movie Database IMDb. His advisory expertise is augmented by decades of involvement with and counsel of national and international computer game publishers and studios. Finally, developments and use of KI technologies across all his expert areas has become a strategic element of his practice.

Ulrich Reber is a certified expert in international business law. Mr. Reber advises and represents German and foreign companies in civil and commercial matters with an emphasis on corporate litigation, for example in commercial and corporate disputes before civil courts and arbitration tribunals. He commands particular expertise in cross-border debt enforcement cases in and out of court. His clients include leading European and non-European companies requiring legal assistance in Germany, to whom he provides corporate legal advice with a special focus on insolvency law. Numerous clients come from the media, entertainment and IT sectors.

Legal expertise – digitally sophisticated

Stefan Schicker has been advising clients at the intersection of law, technology, and innovation for over 20 years. As an experienced and award-winning lawyer specializing in IT and IP law, he assists national and international companies in the legally compliant design of digital business models – from the design of complex internet platforms to the protection of intellectual property.

One of Stefan Schicker's special areas of expertise is the legal structuring of corporate influencer initiatives: with specially developed workshops, he supports companies in setting up corporate LinkedIn communication in a legally compliant and effective manner – in accordance with copyright, personality rights, competition law, etc. – More information.
 

Legal tech & law firm development – with leadership experience

In parallel to his legal practice, Stefan Schicker is one of the most prominent legal tech experts in the German-speaking world. As former COO and CEO of SKW Schwarz, he played a key role in shaping the digital transformation of the law firm – from strategy to operational implementation.

Today, he supports law firms and legal departments in establishing and expanding modern structures:

  • Development and introduction of AI-supported tools
  • Establishing internal teams of experts and training concepts
  • Change processes for the sustainable anchoring of digital working methods
  • Organization of law firms as companies

Stefan Schicker brings a unique combination of legal depth, technological experience, and operational law firm management to the table – recognized, among other things, as one of the “Top 3 Legal Leaders of the Year” (Best of Legal Awards).
 


For companies and law firms that don't want to wait for the future

Whether companies with digital business models or law firms undergoing change: Stefan Schicker combines legal certainty with entrepreneurial foresight – and makes complex transformations understandable, feasible, and effective – More information.

Dr. Tatjana Schroeder has extensive experience in stock corporation law and also accompanies the development of this very specific legal field through regular publications. Stock corporation law also always depends on trends in the capital market and is subject to continuous change.

Mathias Schwarz advises on movie and TV productions, copyright and personality rights, licensing, and media financing. His clients are financial institutions, private investors, movie and TV producers, as well as broadcasting and publishing companies. He also represents a number of renowned individuals in the German media industry. In addition, he has been advising a number of family offices and private clients for a long time.

Marketing Manager
HR assistance
Head of Finance
Head of IT
Head of Marketing & Communication
Head of Business Development
Head of HR
HR Manager
Management Accounting
Legal Tech & Innovation Manager
Business Development and Marketing Manager

News

30

JUVE 2026/27: SKW Schwarz demonstrates a strong profile in trademark, design and competition law

With its latest publication, the JUVE Handbook of Commercial Law Firms 2026/27 continues the announcement of its rankings. Following the results already published for the national overview, media, IT law and M&A, the latest assessment covers the areas of trademark and design law as well as competition law.

SKW Schwarz is recommended by the JUVE Handbook 2026/27 in both areas:

  • Litigation in trademark and design law
  • Litigation in competition law

This recognition reflects a range of legal services extending from strategic brand development to the consistent enforcement of intellectual property rights. The team is particularly sought after by technology-focused companies in the fields of medical technology, digital health and e-commerce. At the same time, SKW Schwarz has many years of experience in complex trademark disputes as well as in combating product piracy and unauthorised distribution channels.

Individual recommendations

JUVE also highlights the expertise of individual members of the team:

  • Dr. Dorothee Altenburg is recommended as a “Leading Name” in trademark law.
  • Dr. Thomas Hohendorf is recognised as a “Rising Star” in trademark and competition law.
  • JUVE also lists Dr. Magnus Hirsch, Dr. Markus Brock, Sandra Sophia Redeker, Dr. Dorothee Altenburg, Markus von Fuchs, Margret Knitter, LL.M., Dr. Rembert Niebel and Dr. Thomas Hohendorf among the frequently recommended lawyers in trademark and competition law.

The latest JUVE results highlight what SKW Schwarz stands for in trademark, design and competition law: a broad-based practice that combines legal precision with strategic insight and provides reliable support to clients, including in challenging contentious matters.

11/10/2026

KI-Flash: Aachen follows Munich. A line may be emerging for AI-generated answers

In July we compared two decisions. The Regional Court of Munich I attributes the “AI Overview” in Google Search to the operator as its own statement, while the Regional Court of Berlin II found that texts generated by artificial intelligence (AI) about “scent twins” did not amount to use of a trade mark by Google. Our outlook at the time was that format, structure and content of the output would be what counts. The Regional Court of Aachen has now expressly followed the Munich reasoning and prohibited Google Ireland Ltd. from disseminating certain statements about a doctor in its “AI Mode”. A line may therefore be emerging for the right of personality, and Munich is taking on an important role for these legal questions.

 

The case

Until mid-2026, the applicant was a chief physician at a university hospital. Anyone who searched Google for his name together with terms such as “release from duties” or “dismissal” received a fully worded account in AI Mode attributing to him criminal proceedings, a conviction, summary dismissals and a settlement in employment court proceedings. These events did happen, but they concerned a former colleague. The AI had linked reporting on that colleague to the applicant’s name. On 28 August 2026, the applicant asked Google to delete the content and set out the facts in detail. On 15 September 2026, Google replied that it had decided not to take any action. A cease-and-desist letter sent the same day was unsuccessful.

 

Aachen adopts Munich’s reasoning

The Regional Court of Aachen granted a claim for injunctive relief for infringement of the general right of personality. In the chamber’s view, the AI Mode outputs are statements of fact; the applicant showed by affidavit that they do not concern him. Google is liable as a so-called “Störer”, a party responsible for the interference irrespective of fault. Following the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, the chamber distinguishes, for search engines, between merely making third-party content findable through links and adopting that content as one’s own (appropriation).

On AI Mode, the chamber quotes two paragraphs of the Munich judgment verbatim. According to that reasoning, the service does not merely display search results with which Google has no connection; it makes independent, new statements of substance based on evaluating and linking the content of different websites. The content of those statements can be checked, at least by comparing the underlying websites with the statements derived from them. Aachen concludes that whoever provides the AI-generated search is directly responsible for the answers generated, including any hallucinations. The chamber adds reasoning of its own at only one point. A check would have been “readily possible” for Google; had it confronted its own AI with the applicant’s objections, it would have found that the statements were false. The court refers to the deletion request and the cease-and-desist letter as additional points; they establish knowledge, support the urgency of the matter and justify the decision without hearing Google.

 

A line may be emerging

With Aachen, there are now two decisions that treat a search engine’s AI answers as Google’s own statements, and the second expressly relies on the first. This is not yet settled case law. Both decisions were issued in interim relief proceedings. Google appealed against the Munich judgment; the appeal before the Higher Regional Court of Munich is reported to have ended in a settlement, so there is no appellate confirmation. Google can lodge an objection against the Aachen order; whether it has done so is not known. The Federal Court of Justice has not yet ruled on the question. A direction may nonetheless be emerging. For the right of personality, the dispute over attributing AI answers has twice been decided the same way at first instance; the limits of liability remain open.

The Berlin judgment does not, in principle, contradict this either. The Regional Court of Berlin II had to answer a trademark question, namely whether Google itself used the claimant’s marks. It found that Google did not, because a reasonable user understands the AI text as a search and information format and every statement was linked. For the right of personality, such use does not matter; it is sufficient that an operator of AI systems formulates and disseminates the statement. Both lines can be reconciled with our July outlook. The format is likely to determine whether operators of AI systems make a statement of their own, and the legal position affected determines what follows from it.

What stands out is where the reasoning comes from. Over the past twelve months, the Regional Court of Munich I has, in addition to the AI Overview, also ruled on training language models with song lyrics in proceedings brought by the German collecting society GEMA against OpenAI, and on AI-generated music; neither judgment is final, and the first is under appeal. Munich currently plays an important role for these legal questions in Germany. In our experience, other courts also take up the Munich line of argument; Aachen even adopted it word for word. Indirectly, this could increase the practical weight of Munich decisions and arguments.

 

What the further decision means for operators of AI systems

With Aachen, the risk increases that the output of an AI system will, in individual cases, be treated as its operator’s own statement. The courts rely on the concept of appropriation, which the Federal Court of Justice developed for adopting third-party content; it would be more accurate to treat the AI answer as original content of the operator. The result is the same either way. If the output is classified this way, operators of AI systems are liable irrespective of fault, no liability exemption for third-party information applies, and liability does not require a prior complaint. Whether the Federal Court of Justice will apply to AI answers the reasonableness limit it set for the autocomplete function remains open.

The Regional Court of Munich I has already held that, in these cases, operators of AI systems cannot rely on the liability exemptions of the Digital Services Act for AI answers. The Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main points in the same direction in a judgment, not yet final, on algorithmically delivered ads and feeds, relying on a judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of June 2026. Under that reasoning, whoever uses auctions, quality scores and ranking algorithms to determine, in its own interest, under which conditions and in which order content appears exercises control over that content and loses the hosting exemption, even without knowledge of the individual content. The court expressly places conventional search, which merely indexes and categorizes content, on the neutral side. In our view, the AI answer may lie on the other side of this line. Operators of AI systems do not merely select sources; they formulate a new statement from them, and the Digital Services Act in any event excludes information developed by the service provider itself from the liability exemptions. For AI answer engines, little room therefore remains for the liability exemption in these cases. Even if a court were to apply the exemption in an individual case, operators of AI systems are likely to be liable for hallucinations at the latest once they have knowledge of them; from that point on, action is always required.

The decisions also address what the courts consider a reasonable check. Operators of AI systems can confront their own AI with the objections of the person concerned and compare the generated statement with the underlying sources. This standard comes from two first-instance decisions and has not yet been confirmed by a highest court either. It does, however, indicate what operators of AI systems should at least document after a complaint, namely which sources support the statement and what the comparison showed.

Anyone who rejects a well-founded complaint across the board risks an injunction without a hearing. The Federal Constitutional Court generally requires that the respondent in interim relief proceedings be given an opportunity to comment before the decision; a prior cease-and-desist letter is only sufficient if the application contains no new submissions. Aachen justified dispensing with a hearing by pointing to the detailed pre-trial account and Google’s active refusal. Whether that holds in every case is open to doubt. For operators of AI systems, it nevertheless remains true that rejecting a complaint without examining its substance weakens their procedural position.

In practice, this means that the complaints process, tracing sources and documenting the review may in future help decide both liability and the course of proceedings.

The question already raised by the Regional Court of Munich I remains open, namely whether remedying the issue after a complaint removes the risk of repetition. Munich did not consider it sufficient simply to switch off a challenged answer, because similar content can be generated again. Aachen did not have to decide the point because Google had refused to take action. Whether the claim for injunctive relief falls away once an operator of AI systems has reacted remains to be seen.

11/06/2026, Moritz Mehner

Photoshop Rebuilt in Four Weeks – What Is Still Protected in Software?

At the end of September 2026, a well-known developer initially published seven free open-source programs on GitHub under the name “ArtCraft”, designed as alternatives to Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere, Lightroom, After Effects, InDesign and Acrobat. In mid-October 2026, this was followed by recreations of Word, Excel and PowerPoint.

The programs were developed in Rust with the assistance of Anthropic’s Claude AI model. The stated objective is complete functional equivalence with the original products, including familiar layouts and workflows. The developer describes the approach as a “clean-room reimplementation” without Adobe code, while some media reports refer to AI-assisted reverse engineering.

The case illustrates just how significantly AI agents can reduce the effort required to recreate complex software. This makes a question previously addressed mainly in principle-based legal decisions into a practical issue for software providers: Which parts of a program are protected against imitation if the code itself is not copied at all?

 

Does Copyright Law Protect Against Functionally Identical Reproductions?
The Code Is Protected, Not the Functionality

Computer programs are protected under Sections 69a et seq. of the German Copyright Act (UrhG). Pursuant to Section 69a(2) UrhG, protection covers all forms of expression of a program, while the ideas and principles underlying any element of a program are expressly excluded. In its SAS Institute judgment (judgment of 2 May 2012 – C-406/10), the CJEU concluded that neither the functionality of a program nor the programming language or the format of data files is protected as a computer program. In its judgment of 17 October 2024 (C-159/23, Sony Computer Entertainment Europe), the CJEU confirmed that protection applies to source code and object code. Merely modifying variables in a computer's memory, without reproducing or altering the code, does not fall within the scope of protection.

For ArtCraft, this means that a program providing the same functions using its own code in a different programming language does not infringe copyright solely because its functionality is identical.

 

Observation Is Permitted, Decompilation Only Within Strict Limits

Anyone entitled to use a program may observe, study and test its functioning in order to identify the ideas and principles underlying it (Section 69d(3) UrhG). This right cannot be excluded by contract either (see Section 69g(2) UrhG).

Decompilation, i.e. converting  object code back into source code, is subject to considerably stricter limitations. Section 69e UrhG permits it only to the extent that it is indispensable for achieving interoperability with an independently created program. The information obtained may expressly not be used to develop a program with substantially similar expression (Section 69e(2) No. 3 UrhG).

This makes the development history of ArtCraft the decisive question. If the AI model worked with publicly available documentation, disclosed file formats (Adobe, for example, publishes a specification of the PSD format) and observed program behaviour, there are strong grounds for considering the approach permissible. By contrast, if the object code of the original programs was decompiled in order to recreate them, this would exceed the limits of Section 69e UrhG.

There is also a contractual dimension. Adobe's and Microsoft's terms of use prohibit using their products to replicate their functionality. Such clauses are binding only on contracting parties and, in Germany, must be assessed against Sections 69d and 69g UrhG as well as Section 307 of the German Civil Code (BGB).

 

User Interface and Design

A graphical user interface is not a form of expression of a computer program and therefore does not fall within the scope of Sections 69a et seq. UrhG. However, it may qualify for protection as an independent work if it constitutes its author's own intellectual creation (CJEU, judgment of 22 December 2010 – C-393/09, BSA). According to the CJEU, elements dictated solely by their technical function do not meet this criterion.

Reproducing an interface with familiar layouts therefore involves a grey area: the usual arrangement of toolbars, layers and menus is likely to be predominantly dictated by functional requirements, whereas individually designed icons and graphic elements are less likely to be. In addition, registered designs under the German Design Act (DesignG) and registered EU designs may be relevant for icons and screen layouts.

 

Unfair Competition Law as the Key Legal Avenue

If the code is not copied but the recreated programs are marketed under their own names, the dispute shifts towards unfair competition law. The German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG) does not protect the program as such. Instead, it focuses on how a reproduction is created and presented on the market.

The provisions of the UWG require a commercial practice, which cannot be taken for granted in the case of a free open-source project. However, ArtCraft's development is reportedly financed through the provider's commercial token business, which may indicate a commercial connection.

 

Protection Against Imitation under Section 4 No. 3 UWG

As a general rule, reproducing a product that is not protected by an specific intellectual property right is permissible (German Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgment of 28 May 2009 – I ZR 124/06, LIKEaBIKE). A reproduction becomes impermissible only when two conditions are met. First, the original product must stand out from comparable products to such an extent that users associate it with a particular manufacturer (so-called competitive individuality). Second, the reproduction must have been created or marketed in an unfair manner. The degree of competitive individuality, the extent of imitation and the other circumstances interact: the closer the reproduction is to the original, the lower the requirements for the other elements.

In the context of software, the question arises as to which characteristics can establish such competitive individuality in the first place. According to the BGH, characteristics that are technically indispensable cannot establish protection. By contrast, designs that serve a technical function but could also have been designed differently may qualify for protection (judgment of 22 January 2015 – I ZR 107/13, Exzenterzähne). Functions, file formats and industry-standard tools such as layers or brushes are therefore generally free for others to use. The specific appearance of an interface, however – including colours, icons and a distinctive arrangement of controls – may indicate the manufacturer of the product.

The law identifies three situations in which a reproduction is unfair. Misleading users as to the commercial origin of a product under Section 4 No. 3(a) UWG occurs if users believe that the program originates from Adobe or an official partner and the provider could have prevented this confusion with reasonable effort. Distinct product names such as PhotoCraft speaks against such deception. However, if the interface looks almost identical to the original, a different name alone may not be sufficient.

It is also impermissible to exploit the reputation of the original product (Section 4 No. 3(b) UWG). It is not enough for the reproduction merely to evoke associations with the original (BGH, judgment of 2 December 2004 – I ZR 30/02, Klemmbausteine III). The reputation must be deliberately transferred to the provider's own product, for example through advertising that relies on Photoshop's reputation.

Finally, it is impermissible to obtain the knowledge used for the reproduction through dishonest means (Section 4 No. 3(c) UWG). This brings us back to the development history. If the original programs' code was decomplied in breach of Section 69e UrhG, this would likely be considered dishonest.

 

Misleading Commercial Practices under Section 5 UWG

In addition to protection against imitation, the impression created by the reproductions among the public is relevant. Under Section 5(3) No. 1 UWG, marketing is misleading if it creates a likelihood of confusion with a competitor's goods or trade mark. This may be particularly relevant where well-known program icons are adopted. In relation to well-known logos, the BGH has held that they may create the impression of an association with the owner of the logo (BGH, judgment of 15 August 2013 – I ZR 188/11, Hard Rock Café). The same is likely to apply to software icons.

Statements about the product itself may also be misleading (Section 5(2) No. 1 UWG). If ArtCraft advertises “complete functional equivalence”, a “clean-room” reproduction without third-party code or full compatibility with Photoshop files, these claims must be accurate. If important functions are missing, files are only partially rendered correctly or third-party code is in fact incorporated into the program, such claims are impermissible.

 

Comparative Advertising under Section 6(2) No. 6 UWG

Section 6(2) No. 6 UWG establishes a separate boundary for comparative advertising, i.e. advertising that identifies a competitor or its product. Such advertising is unfair if it presents a product as an imitation or reproduction of goods marketed under a protected trade mark.

The CJEU interprets this prohibition broadly (judgment of 18 June 2009 – C-487/07, L'Oréal/Bellure). According to the CJEU, the prohibition covers not only counterfeits but any advertising that expressly or implicitly conveys that a product is an imitation. A likelihood of confusion is not required, and the advantage obtained in this way is considered an unfair exploitation of the reputation of the trade mark.

The BGH interprets the provision more narrowly. Merely claiming that a product is equivalent is not sufficient; rather, the advertising itself must clearly indicate that the product is an imitation (judgment of 6 December 2007 – I ZR 169/04, Imitationswerbung). Terms such as “similar” or “like” are generally insufficient on their own (judgment of 2 April 2015 – I ZR 167/13, Staubsaugerbeutel im Internet).

The prohibition is particularly relevant for software reproductions because it requires neither competitive individuality nor deception as to commercial origin. The dividing line lies in the wording used. References to compatibility or describing a product as an “alternative to Photoshop” are likely to be permissible as claims of equivalence. By contrast, terms such as “Photoshop clone” or comparisons along the lines of “PhotoCraft = Photoshop” should be viewed more critically. The fact that ArtCraft is described in media reports as a free reproduction of the Adobe suite is irrelevant in this respect; what matters is the provider's own advertising.

 

What Companies Should Review Now

The case gives rise to different implications depending on the role of the company:

  • Software providers should not rely exclusively on copyright protection of their code. For protection under unfair competition law, the key questions are whether the interface contains design features that indicate commercial origin and are not technically predetermined, and how well-known the product is. Additional protection may be available through registered designs, trade mark protection (including for program icons) and effective provisions governing reverse engineering in licence terms.
  • Companies considering the use of free software reproductions assume the associated risks without any warranty and without indemnification against third-party claims. There are also IT security concerns when using unverified, AI-generated code.
  • Anyone using AI agents themselves to reproduce functions of competitors' products should document the development process: which sources were provided to the model, that no object code was decompiled, and which checks were carried out for third-party code and applicable licences. Equally important are distinctive product identification and interface design, as well as advertising that focuses on compatibility rather than imitation.

 

New Tools, Familiar Boundaries

From a legal perspective, the ArtCraft case is less novel than the headlines might suggest. European copyright law has always protected the code, not the underlying idea. AI primarily changes how quickly and inexpensively these boundaries can be tested.

For providers of the original products, this shifts the focus towards unfair competition law. Whether a reproduction is permissible depends on the individual circumstances: how extensively the interface has been adopted and, above all, how the product is advertised.

Questions remain open as to the extent of protection afforded to user interfaces and how the origin of AI-generated code can be established.

11/04/2026, Veronika Gelser, Dr. Stefan Peintinger, Dr. Daniel Meßmer

SKW Schwarz Recognised for Its Leading Media Practice and Strong Technology Expertise in Germany

The JUVE Handbook 2026/27, one of Germany’s leading independent legal directories, has once again recognised SKW Schwarz among the country’s Top 50 commercial law firms. The latest rankings highlight the firm’s market-leading position in media contract and copyright law and its established expertise in digital and technology-related matters. An improved ranking in data law and the firm’s first inclusion in the media regulation category further reinforce this profile.

JUVE identifies SKW Schwarz as a sought-after adviser on digital and technology-related matters, positioning the firm as an alternative to large law firms, particularly in IT, data protection and media law. Its media contract and copyright practice has consistently ranked among Germany’s market leaders. SKW Schwarz combines this specialist expertise with comprehensive commercial law advice, supporting businesses across the full spectrum of digital business models, technology contracts, data protection, content rights and media regulation, as well as corporate law and technology-related M&A transactions.

Practice Areas Recognised by JUVE

The JUVE Handbook is an independent German legal directory that assesses law firms and lawyers based on market research, including feedback from clients and legal professionals. In its 2026/27 edition, SKW Schwarz is recommended in the following categories:

  • National Overview (JUVE Top 50)
  • Corporate Law
  • Transactions: M&A
  • Media: Contracts and Copyright
  • Media: Regulation (newly ranked)
  • IT and Data Law: IT Contracts and Licensing
  • IT and Data Law: Data Law (improved ranking)

Individual Lawyer Recommendations

The JUVE Handbook 2026/27 also recognises a number of SKW Schwarz lawyers for their expertise:

  • Media Law: Dr. Konstantin Wegner, Dr. Johann Heyde, Dr. Dorothee Altenburg and Dr. Andreas Peschel-Mehner
  • IT and Data Law: Martin Schweinoch, Dr. Matthias Orthwein, Dr. Matthias Nordmann, Franziska Ladiges and Nikolaus Bertermann
  • M&A: Dr. Stephan Morsch and Sebastian Graf von Wallwitz

In addition, Dr. Andreas Peschel-Mehner is recognised as one of the “Leading Names” in copyright law, a distinction highlighting his individual standing in the German legal market.

The JUVE rankings recognise the expertise and dedication of our teams. They also motivate us to continue supporting our clients with outstanding legal expertise, a deep understanding of their business models and practical, commercially focused solutions.

11/03/2026

How Expensive 14 Seconds Can Be – Music on Social Media, Licence Analogy and a Calculation That Didn’t Work Out

14 seconds of music, 383 days online, a claim of EUR 95,750: a TikTok advertising clip for a weight-loss app, featuring the Eurodance classic “Freed from Desire” by Gala, became the subject of a costly legal dispute. In its judgment of 9 September 2026, the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main (Landgericht Frankfurt am Main) dismissed the claim for payment in its entirety – even though it expressly affirmed the copyright infringement and the defendant’s fault. The claim did not fail due to a lack of infringement, but because of an insufficient basis for calculating the licence damages.

 

Available in the Library – But not cleared for commercial use

TikTok provides its users with a music library from which they can select soundtracks for their clips. What many users do not realise is that, under TikTok’s terms and conditions, this general music library is expressly restricted to personal, non-commercial purposes. A separate “Commercial Music Library” is available for commercial content – including advertising, branded posts and the promotion of a company’s own products and services – containing tracks licensed for such uses. “Freed from Desire” was not included in that library.

The defendant, operator of a weight-loss and nutrition app offered internationally, nevertheless used the song as the soundtrack to a TikTok advertising clip. The court found that this constituted a copyright infringement and also held that the defendant had acted negligently. Anyone publishing commercial content on TikTok must familiarise themselves with the platform’s licensing terms and must not assume that a track being technically available also means that it can legally be used without restriction.

 

An infringement does not come with an automatic price tag

The claimant, a rights agency, had a clear idea of the value of its claim: EUR 250 per day of use, multiplied by 383 days of use, resulting in EUR 95,750. The calculation was based on Section 97(2) of the German Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz – UrhG), which allows damages to be calculated on the basis of a hypothetical licence fee (the so-called licence analogy). Under this approach, the infringer must pay the amount that reasonable parties would have agreed upon as remuneration for the specific use.

However, the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main considered itself unable to estimate the damages on that basis under Section 287 of the German Code of Civil Procedure (Zivilprozessordnung – ZPO). This was not because the work’s popularity, the platform’s reach or the duration of use are inherently unsuitable criteria – the court expressly emphasised that they are not. Rather, the claimant simply failed to provide a suitable starting point for a reliable estimate. It submitted neither contracts demonstrating an established licensing practice of its own nor appropriate comparable licence fees. Instead, it argued that licences were negotiated individually on a case-by-case basis.

The court found this insufficient. The absence of comparable figures does not entitle a rights holder to determine licence-based damages unilaterally and without a reliable evidential basis.

 

Why three days don´t simply turn into 383

The claimant also failed to persuade the court with its calculation based on daily rates. The underlying argument was that a marketing manager at a reputable company would have accepted a daily rate of EUR 250 for using the song for three days. That daily rate could then, according to the claimant, be extrapolated to cover the entire period of use.

The court disagreed. A daily rate assumed for a three-day use cannot simply be extrapolated to a period of more than one year. From the court’s perspective, the decisive question was what remuneration reasonable parties would have agreed upon for the entire period of actual use. Even if remuneration were calculated according to the duration of use, a substantial discount would have been expected for a period exceeding one year. The claimant’s own expert report also supported the use of a flat fee.

 

Not every branded post has a “Signature Sound”

The claimant further argued that the song had been used as the defendant’s “signature sound” – a musical calling card for the brand – which would justify a higher licence fee. The court examined the video itself but could not identify any such function.

The clip was just one of many videos on the defendant’s channel. There was no indication that it was a central element of the brand’s communications, was being actively promoted on a significant scale or had been integrated into the app itself. The court acknowledged that there might be a thematic connection between “Freed from Desire” and a weight-loss app. However, that connection was not self-evident, particularly since the video also featured images of sweets.

Not every song used in a branded social media post thereby becomes the brand’s musical identity.

 

No “All-Clear” – But no blank cheque either

The judgment of the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main (judgment of 9 September 2026 – Case No. 2-06 O 424/25, GRUR-RS 2026, 22965) sends two messages.

For companies active on TikTok, the message is clear: the technical availability of a song in the general music library does not constitute a licence for commercial content. Companies producing advertising clips must check whether the intended use is covered by the Commercial Music Library or separately obtain the necessary rights to both the musical composition and the sound recording.

For rights holders, the message is equally important: anyone claiming damages must be able to substantiate the amount claimed. An established licensing practice of their own is not strictly necessary. Suitable comparable licence fees and other reliable circumstances of the individual case may also provide a basis for an estimate.

The licence analogy requires an objective licence value – something the court cannot estimate out of thin air if the claimant itself provides no reliable points of reference.

Fourteen seconds of music can be expensive. But the amount must be capable of being justified in a comprehensible and substantiated manner.

10/29/2026, Maximilian König

AI Regulation Worldwide: Key Legal Requirements Businesses Need to Know

10/26/2026, Dr. Martin Böttger, Johannes Schäufele, Moritz Mehner

KI-Flash: What advertisers and agencies are responsible for when booking ads in AI assistants

Since 24 August 2026, ads have been shown in ChatGPT in Germany to users of the free version and the Go plan. Since 31 August 2026, companies based in Germany, Austria and Switzerland can also book them themselves through the provider’s ads manager, which is in beta. The existing routes through the provider’s ads solutions team and through agency and technology partners remain available. The two previous articles in this series dealt with the provider’s obligations. This article changes sides and asks what the booking party is responsible for itself.

There is hardly any literature on this question yet. That is due to the novelty of the channel and to the fact that public attention is focused on the provider. For companies, the booking side is nonetheless the more pressing one in practice. The provider’s obligations are met by the provider. In case of doubt, nobody else will meet the advertiser’s obligations.

 

At a glance

  • Anyone placing an ad in an AI assistant is, in principle, responsible for labelling it and should record how it is actually delivered.
  • Infringements by an agency could be attributed to the client without any possibility of exculpation. An approval process, documentation and the question of who holds the ad account should therefore be laid down in the contract.
  • Anyone who leaves a default setting for automatic adjustment of ad texts switched on will not be able to blame the machine when it comes to responsibility for the delivered text. In regulated sectors, the consequences can extend to criminal liability.
  • Anyone using the provider’s pixel for measurement could be a joint controller with the provider in that respect.
  • The provider’s category exclusions do not replace a review of the sector-specific advertising bans.

 

Does the advertiser have to label the ad itself?

Section 5a(4) of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG) applies to anyone who fails to disclose the commercial purpose of their own commercial practice. An advertiser placing an ad is therefore, in principle, subject to the provision in its own right and should not rely on the platform to label the ad correctly. The same applies to No. 11 of the Annex to Section 3(3) UWG. It covers editorial-looking content used for sales promotion, paid for by the trader and disguised as information. That use will usually be paid for by the advertiser, regardless of who implements the labelling technically.

In practice, this creates a documentation burden. How the ad is actually labelled in the delivery environment and set apart from the answer text should be recorded with a date. If the provider changes the format, the basis of the advertiser’s own assessment changes without the advertiser being informed.

 

Who is liable when the agency books?

In Germany, purchasing initially ran exclusively through agency and technology partners, and a large share is likely to continue doing so. This raises the question of whom the obligations apply to. The advertiser is the party whose sales are promoted. Infringements by the agency could therefore be attributed to the client under Section 8(2) UWG, without any possibility of exculpation by showing careful selection and supervision.

The agency is also liable for its own contributions under general principles. If it designs the ad or contributes to it, it is liable as a primary infringer. Checking the ad for compliance with competition law then also forms part of its contractual obligations towards the client. A media agency that merely places advertising without knowing its content, by contrast, is only liable for infringements that can be recognised with reasonable effort.

Against attribution, it can be argued that the agency is not an agent within the meaning of Section 8(2) UWG if it has no latitude over the content. Case law on affiliates requires decisive influence on the context, type and content of the advertising. If the agency runs the ad account in the client’s name and for the client’s account, that in principle points towards integration.

Whether Section 8(2) UWG also applies to the provider of the ad system is less clear than it first appears. The agent must be integrated into the business organisation, and the business owner must have decisive and enforceable influence over it. In ordinary advertising business, this should be lacking between the advertiser and the publisher. The publisher is, however, an agent if the advertiser has given it creative latitude. That is exactly the issue here. Leaving the default setting for automatic text adjustment switched on gives the provider creative latitude over the ad text. That speaks for treating this constellation differently from ordinary advertising business.

 

What should be agreed in the contract

When drafting the contract, the client should provide for an approval process for the text in the version that is actually delivered, documentation of this approval and a provision on who holds the ad account. The last point seems technical, but it also determines the allocation of roles under data protection law and access to the campaign data after the contract ends. Indemnity clauses only take effect between the parties. Externally, the client remains responsible, which is why the agreed labelling should also be monitored and, if necessary, enforced.

 

Who is liable for automatically rewritten ad text?

Practitioners report that ad systems automatically adjust submitted ad texts, in some cases through an active default setting. Whether and to what extent this happens in the German market needs to be examined in each case.

The legal question can be asked independently of this. Where an ad system changes the submitted text before delivery, it has to be clarified whose commercial practice the delivered text is. The answer is likely to depend also on whether the advertiser triggered the change and whether it can approve the delivered version before it goes live.

Case law on keyword advertising already provides a standard for this, and it fits the case more closely than it first appears. According to the judgment of the Federal Court of Justice of 13 December 2012 (I ZR 217/10), anyone who chooses the standard option for broadly matching keywords has also selected the keywords added by the algorithm for their advertising purposes. An activated default setting that adjusts the submitted ad text is likely to be comparable.

The limit, in turn, is shown by a decision of the Higher Regional Court of Schleswig of 28 September 2017 (6 U 18/17): if the search engine operator’s algorithm independently links a third party’s trade mark, the party ordering the ad has not made an adequately causal contribution. From the point at which it is notified of the infringement, however, that party is liable as an interferer (Störer), because a check can reasonably be expected of it. The dividing line should therefore run along the foreseeability of the change and the point in time at which the advertiser becomes aware of it.

Case law on automatically generated content provides further support. In the contract document generator case, the Federal Court of Justice held in its judgment of 9 September 2021 (I ZR 113/20) that programming software and the results it produces cannot be split into separate processes but are dependent parts of a single activity. The decision concerns the generation of content, not the modification of a submitted text, so applying it to the present case remains our own assessment.

The change is at the same time a commercial practice of the provider. According to case law, anyone who initiates an automated evaluation acts within the scope of their own commercial communication, and the activity is not purely technical and passive if the content is generated by their own program. For the booking party, this means that it does not stand alone. In practice, the question thus shifts to the contract with the provider and whether it provides for recourse.

In areas where the wording determines whether advertising is permissible, this is not a theoretical consideration. Within the scope of the German Healthcare Advertising Act (HWG), a single reworded claim of efficacy can decide whether the entire advertisement is permissible. Section 3 sentence 2 no. 1 HWG prohibits attributing to a remedy a therapeutic effect that it does not have, and the advertiser must demonstrate and prove the scientific basis of the claim. How the text came about is irrelevant. Infringements of Section 3 HWG are also a criminal offence under Section 14 HWG. Where the automatic function can be switched off, there is therefore a good case for switching it off. Where it cannot, regular checks of the delivered version remain necessary.

 

Responsibility for measurement

If the advertiser uses one of the provider’s measurement tools on its own website, it is processing data itself. Section 25 of the German Telecommunications Digital Services Data Protection Act (TDDDG) applies to access to information on terminal equipment, for the party that initiates the access. The fact that the provider’s pixel sets a cookie on the advertiser’s own domain does not change the need for consent, because the provision does not distinguish between first and third parties. Section 25 TDDDG does not, by contrast, apply to server-side transmission via the conversion interface, because there is no access to terminal equipment; the GDPR alone is the yardstick in this respect. This applies only insofar as no values are passed on that were previously read from the terminal device, such as the click identifier stored in the cookie.

The allocation of roles under the GDPR depends on who determines the purposes and means of processing. Anyone who merely selects a targeting logic specified by the provider decides less than someone who contributes their own data. According to OpenAI’s documentation, advertisers currently cannot upload their own customer lists for campaigns targeting the European Economic Area or Switzerland, because personalised advertising is not yet offered there. This speaks against joint controllership for audience building.

The opposite applies to measurement. In Fashion ID, according to the judgment of the CJEU of 29 July 2019 (C-40/17), integrating a third-party measurement tool is already enough to establish joint controllership for the collection and transmission of the data, because the website operator enables it and has its own economic interest in it. Joint controllership ends where the provider further processes the data, since the advertiser has no decisive influence over that. The allocation of roles must therefore be determined phase by phase and not for the campaign as a whole.

Case law on advertising in social networks is the starting point for the assessment, but it cannot simply be transferred, because there the target group was formed on the basis of characteristics determined by the advertiser itself.

One point is regularly underestimated in practice: measurement data is personal data, and hashed identifiers are pseudonymised and therefore still personal data. It is unresolved whether their transmission also constitutes processing of special categories of data under Art. 9 GDPR where conclusions about health or other sensitive characteristics can be drawn from the context.

 

An environment without a results list

Anyone advertising in a classic search environment appears next to results that the operator conveys. In an AI assistant, the ad appears in between text that the Munich Regional Court I and the Commission on Licensing and Supervision of the German media authorities (ZAK) have attributed to the provider as its own statement. Neither decision is final; the previous article in this series discusses them. For the advertiser, this shifts the risk profile. The text next to its ad may be incorrect and is at the same time attributable to a provider that has to answer for it.

In addition, according to the provider’s information, placement in a specific conversation is not guaranteed. Delivery is apparently steered through context hints that describe conversational situations, topics or keywords; they do not guarantee delivery in specific conversations. Traditional placement exclusions can therefore only be reproduced to a limited extent. What remains to be clarified contractually is which response channels exist if an answer next to the ad is incorrect or damaging to reputation, and whether the advertiser can demand that delivery be suspended.

 

Sector-specific advertising bans and the provider’s category exclusions

Sector-specific advertising bans continue to apply unchanged in the AI environment, in particular:

  • the HWG for remedies,
  • Section 5 of the Interstate Treaty on Gambling (GlüStV) for gambling,
  • the Securities Trading Act (WpHG) and MiFID II for financial instruments,
  • the Tobacco Products Act (TabakerzG) for tobacco products,
  • the Food Information to Consumers Regulation and the Health Claims Regulation for food, and
  • the Price Indication Ordinance (PAngV) for price indications.

Their application in the AI environment does, however, have one particular feature. Ad selection depends on the topic of the ongoing conversation. A user describing symptoms is therefore the normal case of audience building, not an edge case. What would be wasted coverage in a traditional environment is how the system works here.

The provider’s category exclusions are contractual requirements. They do not cover the statutory limits.

Four examples show how different the requirements are. Section 5(2) GlüStV prohibits advertising that gives the impression of being editorial content, which is an obvious risk next to an AI answer. Section 19(3) TabakerzG prohibits advertising for tobacco products in information society services and therefore also in an AI assistant service. The Health Claims Regulation works with positive lists, so any health claim that has not been authorised is inadmissible, even if it only arises through automated adjustment. And under Section 1 PAngV, the price must remain clearly allocated to the offer and easily recognisable, which has to be checked specifically where the ad text has been changed.

Elsewhere, the exclusions go further than the law: according to the advertising policies (as of 10 September 2026), regulated industries outside the United States are in part completely excluded from booking. Advertising for legal services is currently completely excluded outside the United States; the same applies to health and financial services, with individual exceptions that apply only in the United States. For companies in these sectors, the assessment therefore begins with the question of access.

 

Brands in the ad environment

By judgment of 1 June 2026 (52 O 62/26), the Berlin Regional Court II rejected an application by a perfume group. The court held that there was no use as a trade mark under Art. 9 EUTMR, because the search engine operator was creating a new format for search results and was not engaging in its own commercial communication. These are interim injunction proceedings, and the decision is not final.

The reasoning does not, however, support an application to advertising. The court relied on the fact that the texts reflected the actual search results, that every statement was backed by a link to a search result, and that no targeted selection or steering in favour of individual providers was apparent. These three features are missing in paid ad selection. Paying for placement brings about steering in favour of a single provider, and the ad text is not backed by any organic search result.

The Berlin line cannot be relied on for attribution to the advertiser in any event. It concerns whether the operator creates its own format, not whether a booked ad is the advertiser’s commercial communication. There is still no ruling from the highest courts on the operator’s own liability.

 

What remains open

Above all, what remains unresolved for this channel is the attribution of the delivered ad text. German competition law regulates the attribution of agents’ conduct to the business owner in Section 8(2) UWG. It has no specific rule for the case where an ad system changes the advertiser’s text. Until this is resolved, the practical rule is: Anyone who leaves the automatic function switched on and does not check the delivered version will not be able to blame the machine.

We would be pleased to support you in reviewing your campaigns in the AI environment, in designing agency agreements and approval processes, and in assessing the allocation of roles under data protection law.

Further reading:

10/20/2026, Moritz Mehner, Helena Kasper, Yannik Rothweiler

Cannabis Telemedicine in Germany: Navigating the Legal Landscape

The provision of medical cannabis through telemedicine services creates new opportunities for patients. At the same time, it presents providers, platforms and treating physicians with complex legal requirements.

Margret Knitter, LL.M., Partner at SKW Schwarz, has analysed the key developments in a contributed article for the US-based trade publication Cannabis & Tech Today.

The article focuses on the requirements for prescribing medical cannabis via telemedicine, physicians’ professional independence and the specific requirements applicable to cross-border services within the European Union.

Advertising law is of particular importance. Under Section 9 of the German Healthcare Advertising Act (HWG), advertising for remote treatment is generally permitted only under certain conditions. In addition, Section 10 HWG generally prohibits advertising prescription-only medicines to the general public, including medical cannabis. Broad promises of a straightforward online prescription may therefore give rise to legal risks.

Planned amendments to the German Medical Cannabis Act could also have a significant impact on the industry. Among other things, they would require in-person consultations before prescribing cannabis flowers and introduce restrictions on mail-order dispensing. The amendments have not yet been adopted.

In her full article in Cannabis & Tech Today, Margret Knitter explains the requirements applicable to telemedicine-based medical cannabis services in Germany, outlines the key legal developments and discusses their implications for providers and platforms.

10/19/2026, Margret Knitter

AI Retrofits in Manufacturing: When Do Operators Become Manufacturers?

Many production machines are mechanically far from reaching the end of their service life. Digitally, however, they are often no longer up to date. Instead of replacing an entire system, companies retrofit it with cameras, sensors and AI systems.

This can be economically attractive. However, modifying a machine can also cause a company to assume additional manufacturer responsibilities. Anyone who purchases a finished machine and uses it as intended is generally considered its operator. Anyone who makes substantial modifications to it may become a manufacturer themselves.

 

When Robots Learn to See

An example of what an AI retrofit can look like is an application at Stellantis described by the New York Times. An older industrial robot at a plant in Detroit had difficulty picking up body parts when they were not positioned exactly where expected. Instead of replacing it, the robot was retrofitted with a camera, a computing unit and an AI system.

The system detects the position and orientation of the component and sends corrected coordinates to the robot. The robot can then adapt its movement accordingly. The technical operation is also described in a supplementary publication by the provider Inbolt.

Here, AI improves the production process. However, its outputs also influence the machine's movements. This raises the question of the potential safety consequences of incorrect detection.

AI can also be used specifically to protect people. This approach is being investigated in the Fraunhofer PROTECT project. The camera-based system distinguishes people from automated guided vehicles and enables the robot's speed to be adjusted according to the situation. AI-based recognition is combined with conventional motion detection.

PROTECT therefore illustrates another potential application in which AI is directly integrated into the safety concept. Whether implementing this approach on an existing machine would constitute a substantial modification would need to be assessed separately.

For a retrofit, the decisive factor is not simply which technology is added. What matters is how it changes the machine's behaviour and which protective measures are consequently required.

 

When Does an Operator Become a Manufacturer?

The EU Machinery Regulation, which applies from 20 January 2027, defines when a subsequent modification is considered substantial. This requires a physical or digital modification that was not envisaged or planned by the original manufacturer and that creates a new hazard or increases an existing risk. In addition, the modification must make additional safeguards, whether physical or non-physical, necessary, with their integration requiring an adjustment to the existing safety control system. Alternatively, additional protective measures must be necessary to ensure stability or mechanical strength. Not every change to a movement sequence or safety function meets these criteria.

For an AI retrofit, it must therefore be assessed on a case-by-case basis whether incorrect detection could trigger hazardous movements, whether the existing safety concept already addresses these risks and which additional protective measures are necessary.

Based on the publicly available information, it is not possible to determine whether the Stellantis retrofit meets these criteria. The legal assessment of such a modification requires a risk assessment of the specific case.

If a substantial modification has been made, the person carrying it out is considered the manufacturer of the modified machine. This may be the existing operator. If a system integrator is commissioned to carry out a substantial modification, the actual division of responsibilities is decisive.

 

The New Role Brings New Obligations

The new manufacturer must ensure the conformity of the modified machine under its own responsibility. This includes the risk assessment, technical documentation and the applicable conformity assessment procedure, including the EU Declaration of Conformity and CE marking.

Implementation can be particularly complex for older systems. If technical documents, information about the control architecture or the necessary access rights are missing, the modification may only be possible to assess and document with the support of the original manufacturer. In addition to the camera, software and integration, companies must also plan for safety evidence and potential delays before the machine can be put back into operation.

 

How the AI Act Comes into Play

Not every AI system used in a production facility qualifies as high-risk AI. For product-related systems, classification generally requires that the AI is a safety component or constitutes a product covered by the relevant legislation, and that the product is subject to a conformity assessment by an independent body.

For machinery, the current version of the AI Act contains a special provision. The general high-risk requirements and provider obligations do not apply directly to these product-related systems in the same way as they do to other high-risk AI systems. An AI retrofit therefore does not automatically make the operator a provider under Article 25 of the AI Act as well.

Instead, the intention is to incorporate the relevant AI requirements into the Machinery Regulation through supplementary legal acts. These must become applicable by 2 August 2028. For retrofits, manufacturer responsibility for the modified machine therefore remains the central starting point.

 

Practical Advice for Operators and System Integrators

Before commissioning a third party to carry out an AI retrofit, companies should document the machine's existing condition, the planned modification and the safety functions affected. This provides a basis for determining whether the modification is substantial and who will assume the resulting manufacturer obligations.

The contract should clearly specify who is responsible for the safety assessment and any conformity assessment that may be required. Responsibilities under public law cannot be freely reassigned by contract. However, the support the company needs to fulfil its obligations should be secured in a binding agreement before the modification begins.

10/14/2026, Dr. Daniel Meßmer

The Forger Wants His Painting Back

Wolfgang Beltracchi is seeking the return of the “Red Painting with Horses.” After defeats in two court instances, he has achieved an initial success before the Federal Court of Justice. A legal question with implications far beyond the art market is now awaiting a decision.

An art forger seeking the return of his own forgery is an unusual claimant. On 9 October 2026, the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) in Karlsruhe heard Wolfgang Beltracchi’s lawsuit. He wants to recover the “Red Painting with Horses” which he once introduced into the art market as a work by Heinrich Campendonk. The BGH’s Fifth Civil Senate must determine who owns the painting following the unwinding of the original sale.

The story begins in 2005. Beltracchi painted an oil canvas in the style of Expressionist artist Heinrich Campendonk, signed it with Campendonk’s name and dated it 1914. On the reverse, he attached forged collector’s labels, including one purporting to refer to the renowned Flechtheim Gallery in Düsseldorf. The alleged Jäger family collection, from which the painting was supposedly sourced, was also entirely fictitious.

The deception succeeded. In 2006, the Cologne auction house Lempertz included the painting in its catalogue as an allegedly authentic Campendonk. The estimated price ranged from €800,000 to €1.2 million. At the “Modern Art” auction, the painting fetched a hammer price of €2.4 million. Including additional fees, the buyer paid €2.88 million.

However, the success did not last. The forgery was discovered, exposing Beltracchi’s years-long art fraud. In October 2011, the Criminal Division of the Cologne Higher Regional Court sentenced him to several years in prison. This marked the criminal-law conclusion of one of the biggest forgery scandals in German art history.

The matter was far from resolved under civil law. The buyer demanded a refund and sued the auction house. In September 2012, the Cologne Higher Regional Court ordered Lempertz to pay damages in exchange for the return of the painting. The auction house had offered the painting in its catalogue as an authentic Campendonk without having sufficiently substantiated that attribution. The legal dispute eventually ended in a settlement before the Cologne Appeal Court. Lempertz recovered the painting and subsequently sold it to a third party.

This took the story in an unexpected direction. Beltracchi now demanded that the new owner surrender the painting. He maintains that ownership reverted to him when the original sale was unwound. Consequently, he argues, the auction house could neither acquire ownership nor validly resell the work.

At the heart of the dispute lies a fundamental question of German property law. In a commission transaction, an auction house sells in its own name but on behalf of the consignor. It does not own the painting itself, but with the consent of the person entitled to dispose of it, it may transfer ownership to the buyer. But what happens when the buyer withdraws from the purchase and returns the painting? Does the auction house become the owner through the transfer back to it, even though it never owned the work in the first place? Or does ownership revert directly to the original owner?

Beltracchi has so far lost his case at two levels of court. The Freiburg Higher Regional Court dismissed his claim in autumn 2022. He was also unsuccessful before the Karlsruhe Appeal Court, which upheld the lower court’s decision in November 2024. In the judges’ view, ownership of the painting was transferred back solely between the buyer and the auction house. Beltracchi was not a party to the settlement, nor could any acquisition of ownership in his favour be derived from its terms.

The judges also found no legal basis for ownership to revert automatically to the original owner. They relied on a 2002 decision by the Federal Court of Justice, in which the BGH had already recognised the reacquisition of ownership by a party who had not originally been entitled to it in a different legal context. The Appeal Court saw no reason to treat the present case differently.

There is an additional, unusual aspect to this case. Beltracchi had deliberately deceived the parties involved and caused millions of euros in losses through the sale. He had already received the auction proceeds. The judges of the Appeal Court did not consider it deserving of legal protection for him to derive ownership rights from the unwinding of the transaction as well.

The legal dispute therefore appeared to have been settled. The Appeal Court had dismissed the appeal by order without an oral hearing and refused leave to appeal to the Federal Court of Justice, finding that the case raised no question of fundamental significance. Beltracchi, however, refused to accept this outcome and lodged a complaint against the refusal of leave to appeal with the BGH.

He succeeded: the Fifth Civil Senate of the BGH admitted the appeal itself. This represents an initial legal milestone for Beltracchi, although it says nothing yet about the ultimate outcome of the proceedings. The federal judges evidently consider there to be sufficient grounds to resolve the disputed question of ownership themselves. They may, of course, still uphold the Karlsruhe Appeal Court’s position.

During the oral hearing, Beltracchi’s lawyer argued that there was a gap in the law governing the unwinding of the transaction, since Lempertz had not previously owned the painting and had not acquired ownership with the forger’s consent. The opposing side argued that a specific form of unwinding the transaction — namely, the return of ownership to the former owner — should have been expressly stipulated by contract. Otherwise, ownership would remain with the auction house.

A ruling by the highest civil court could have implications extending far beyond the art market. After all, questions concerning ownership also arise in other commission transactions. The decisions of the lower courts had already hinted that the parties would be well advised to regulate the transfer of ownership in unambiguous terms when unwinding such transactions.

Thus, almost twenty years after it was auctioned, the “Red Painting with Horses” is once again keeping the courts occupied. The identity of its painter has long been established. Its owner, however, remains to be determined. The man who once introduced it into the art market as the work of another artist now wants it back as his own. The Federal Court of Justice is scheduled to announce its decision on 15 January 2027.

10/14/2026, Dr. Dorothee Altenburg

Digital Business 2027: SKW Schwarz provides insights into the legal framework in Germany

Digital business knows no borders. Legal requirements, however, vary from country to country. For companies offering digital products and services internationally or looking to enter new markets, understanding these differences is essential.

This is where Lexology Panoramic: Digital Business 2027 comes in. The international publication provides an overview of the legal requirements for digital business across different jurisdictions. Using a consistent set of questions, it allows readers to compare legal frameworks and identify key differences between markets.

SKW Schwarz has once again authored the Germany chapter. Franziska Ladiges, Matthias Orthwein, Stefan Peintinger, Johannes Schäufele and Daniel Meßmer provide a comprehensive overview of the legal landscape for digital businesses in Germany. They were supported by Fabian Bauer, Corinna Schneiderbauer, Veronika Gelser, Moritz Mehner, Thomas Hausbeck, Maximilian König and Oliver Bühr.

The chapter covers a broad range of topics, from e-commerce, digital contracts and platform regulation to data protection, intellectual property, artificial intelligence and cybersecurity. It also addresses recent developments in European digital regulation, including the EU AI Act, Data Act, Cyber Resilience Act and NIS2, and explains what these requirements mean for businesses operating in Germany.

Through its contribution to the Germany chapter, SKW Schwarz brings its cross-practice expertise in advising digital and technology-driven businesses to this international legal comparison.

Read the Germany chapter of Lexology Panoramic: Digital Business 2027: click here

10/12/2026, Franziska Ladiges, Dr. Matthias Orthwein, Dr. Stefan Peintinger, Johannes Schäufele, Dr. Daniel Meßmer

Handelsblatt Ranking: SKW Schwarz wins “Law Firm of the Year” award in Media Law

Best Lawyers and Handelsblatt have identified “Germany’s Best Law Firms 2026” – and we are delighted: SKW Schwarz has been named “Law Firm of the Year” in the field of Media Law.

What makes this especially rewarding is the fact that the rankings are based on Best Lawyers’ peer‑to‑peer principle. The decisive factor is how often law firms are recommended by other legal professionals. Lawyers vote for those colleagues whom they value professionally and consider particularly recommendable. Against this backdrop, SKW Schwarz being named “Law Firm of the Year” in media law is a strong signal of our reputation in the industry.

There is even more reason to celebrate: SKW Schwarz is also listed as a leading firm in numerous other areas of law – both nationally and regionally. The ranking shows that we support our clients broadly and at a high level in key future areas of business law: from data protection, IT and IP to employment law and M&A, all the way to tax and technology matters.

We would like to thank the colleagues who recommended us and our teams for their outstanding commitment. These awards motivate us to continue working on innovative solutions with high professional expertise, pragmatism, and enthusiasm.

Our awards in detail:

Law Firm of the Year

  • Media Law

National: Tier 1

  • Data Security and Privacy Law
  • Information Technology Law
  • Intellectual Property Law
  • Media Law
  • Tax Law

National: Tier 2

  • Labor and Employment Law
  • Mergers and Acquisitions Law

National: Tier 3

  • Corporate Law 
  • Litigation
  • Restructuring and Insolvency Law

Further information about our awards can be found on the Handelsblatt website. 

10/09/2026

KI-Flash: ChatGPT as a very large online search engine under the Digital Services Act

On 31 August 2026, the European Commission designated ChatGPT as a very large online search engine (VLOSE) under the Digital Services Act (DSA). It is the first designation of a generative AI service. Reddit and Roblox were classified as very large online platforms (VLOP) on the same day. All three services had reported to the Commission that they meet the threshold of 45 million average monthly users in the Union under Article 33(1) DSA. For ChatGPT, OpenAI reported around 159.1 million users of its search functions for the six-month period ending 31 March 2026.

The designation coincided closely with the launch of advertising: ads had gone live in Germany a week earlier, and self-service access through the Ads Manager opened on the same day.

This article is the second part of a three-part series on current developments around AI assistants. The first part set out the advertising and data protection standards applying to the advertising model (available here). This part looks at the obligations that follow from the designation, at the gaps the DSA may leave for advertising in AI assistants, and at the supervisory bodies that have a say alongside the Commission. Like the first part, it is addressed to companies that advertise in this environment or deploy AI assistants in their own operations. The third part deals with the responsibility and liability of advertisers and agencies.

 

ChatGPT as a search engine

The Commission bases the classification as a search engine on the fact that the service accesses internet content directly when answering queries. OpenAI has not contested the designation and has stated that the search function of ChatGPT operates as a search service within the meaning of the DSA. The DSA was designed for classic platforms and search engines and contains no separate category for generative systems of this kind. The Commission has therefore applied an existing framework to a new type of service.

The designation starts a four-month period (Article 33(6) DSA) which, according to the Commission, expires around the turn of the year 2026/2027. Section 5 of Chapter III DSA then applies. It covers the assessment of systemic risks under Article 34 and their mitigation under Article 35, expressly including advertising systems, as well as independent audits under Article 37, the advertisement repository under Article 39, data access for researchers under Article 40, extended transparency reporting under Article 42 and the annual supervisory fee under Article 43. Articles 37, 39 and 40 DSA, which the first part identified as starting points for verifying the provider’s promise that advertising does not influence its answers, therefore only apply from that date. For Section 5, supervisory and enforcement competence lies exclusively with the Commission.

 

An asymmetry in the DSA advertising rules

By its wording, Article 39(1) DSA addresses „providers of very large online platforms or of very large online search engines“. The substantive advertising requirements in Section 3, by contrast, consistently address only „providers of online platforms“: Article 25 on the design of the online interface, Article 26 on the labelling of advertising and on profiling using special categories of data, Article 27 on the transparency of recommender systems and Article 28 on the protection of minors, including the prohibition of profiling-based advertising directed at minors. On the wording, OpenAI as a VLOSE is therefore subject to the repository obligation, but not to the requirements on labelling, transparency of recommender systems, manipulative design and targeting of minors.

This literal reading is not undisputed. It is argued in the literature that Article 26 DSA applies at least to advertising-funded online search engines, and that the transparency requirements for recommender systems extend functionally to very large online search engines via Article 38 DSA. The asymmetry produces the inconsistencies described above and is accordingly the subject of ongoing debate. Advertisers and providers would be well advised not to rely on the gap in the wording holding in the long run.

It should also be noted that the Commission has designated ChatGPT as a VLOSE, but has not thereby decided that the service is not also an online platform within the meaning of Article 3(i) DSA. If it also meets the platform criteria, the provisions of Section 3 could apply in addition.

There are several starting points for that argument. Article 3(i) DSA requires a hosting service that stores information at the request of a recipient and disseminates it to the public. That applies first of all to the advertisements themselves, which the provider stores and displays on behalf of its advertising customers. It may also apply to features that allow users to make their own content publicly accessible, such as sharing individual conversations through retrievable links or offering self-configured assistants in a public directory. Whether such features qualify as a minor and purely ancillary feature within the meaning of Article 3(i) DSA determines whether the platform classification holds.

 

German media law is already engaged

Alongside the DSA, German authorities have been applying German media law since July 2026. On 14 July 2026, in two proceedings conducted by the state media authorities of Hamburg/Schleswig-Holstein and Berlin-Brandenburg, the Commission on Licensing and Supervision (ZAK) issued its first decisions against AI services, concerning Google’s AI Overviews and Perplexity. It found that AI answers are the providers’ own content and that the liability exemption under the DSA does not apply to them. The levers used are the diversity rules for media intermediaries under sections 91 to 94 of the Interstate Media Treaty (MStV), in particular the transparency requirement and the non-discrimination rule, which in principle presuppose the transmission of third-party information. Google has announced an appeal; the decisions are not yet final.

The proceedings concerned Google and Perplexity. Whether the reasoning can be transferred to ChatGPT is likely to depend on how source selection and linking are designed in detail. On the distinction set out in the first part, classification as a media intermediary requires that the service aggregates third-party content, selects it and determines how easily it can be found, without combining it into an overall offering of its own, which is difficult to assume for content that providers generate themselves and are liable for. It is disputed in the literature whether presenting generated answers is sufficient or whether visibly displayed third-party content with an identifiable source reference is required. An expert opinion commissioned by the state media authorities concludes that large language models are to be classified as media intermediaries to the extent that they reproduce source links within their own generated answers. That is said to apply only where the sources are not given as mere evidence, but as „further sources“, with the result that third-party content is transmitted. How that distinction is to look in practice is left open.

 

Two supervisory regimes side by side

If ChatGPT were both a media intermediary under sections 91 et seq. MStV and a VLOSE under the DSA, two supervisory structures would meet: the state media authorities on one side, and on the other the Commission, which is solely competent for Section 5, together with Coimisiún na Meán as Digital Services Coordinator for the remaining obligations given the Irish establishment. Between them stands the country-of-origin principle under section 3 of the Digital Services Act implementation statute (DDG) and Article 3 of Directive 2000/31/EC. Whether section 93 MStV is enforceable against providers established in another Member State has been left open by the Administrative Court of Berlin and the Higher Administrative Court of Schleswig, which referred the question to the Court of Justice of the European Union. In Germany, the Federal Network Agency also acts as Digital Services Coordinator; the lead data protection authority is the Irish Data Protection Commission.

There is also the allocation of competence under the German AI market surveillance act (KI-MIG), which the first part described for Article 50 AI Act: the Federal Network Agency is the central market surveillance authority, while for media services serving journalistic or advertising purposes the authorities competent under state law remain responsible under section 2(8) KI-MIG. The question of competence therefore needs clarification both between the Union and state level and within German supervision. We have set out the draft Interstate Treaty on Digital Media and the allocation of competence it provides for in a separate article (available here).

 

What the enforcement pattern shows so far

The Commission has concluded three DSA cases with a fine to date. On 5 December 2025, X was fined 120 million euros for the misleading design of its verification mark, an incomplete advertisement repository and insufficient data access for researchers, all of them verifiable transparency obligations. On 28 May 2026, a fine of 200 million euros against Temu followed, and on 20 July 2026 a fine of 550 million euros against AliExpress. In both cases the focus was not on transparency obligations but on the assessment and mitigation of systemic risks in connection with illegal, unsafe or counterfeit products. In the Temu case, according to the Commission, the risk assessment relied on general information about risks in the e-commerce sector instead of evidence relating to the service itself.

For ChatGPT, the second line may be the more informative one, because the risk assessment is among the first obligations to apply once the period expires. In the Temu case in particular, the Commission did not merely check whether an assessment had been submitted, but whether it holds up in substance. Fines may reach up to six per cent of worldwide annual turnover; the amounts imposed so far have remained well below that.

 

Consequences for the advertising system

The advertising system went live a week before the designation and must feed into the first systemic risk assessment before the period expires. Article 34(1)(b) and (d) DSA covers negative effects on fundamental rights, including consumer protection and the rights of the child, as well as on the protection of minors and on physical and mental well-being. Under Article 34(2) DSA, the systems for selecting and displaying advertising are among the factors to be taken into account in the risk assessment. The selection of ads by the topic of the ongoing conversation, described in the first part, should therefore be subject to that assessment, regardless of whether Article 26 DSA applies on its wording.

 

What comes next

Two developments are on the horizon. At Union level, the Commission is expected to propose a Digital Fairness Act in the fourth quarter of 2026, focusing on manipulative interface design, unfair personalisation and the protection of minors. At state level, the Broadcasting Commission discussed the draft of an Interstate Treaty on Digital Media (part 2) on 16 September 2026. Under that draft, providers of AI information systems are to be responsible for the content these systems generate. One option under consideration is to treat AI services as media intermediaries, another to create a new category of telemedia. The public consultation is still planned for 2026.

The expiry of the period around the turn of the year will show how the Commission assesses the risk assessment of a conversational service. Until then, the question that matters most for companies that deploy such services or advertise in them is which supervisory regime governs their own role. The third part of the series addresses that role.

If you have questions about the regulatory classification of your campaigns or of your use of AI assistants, or about what the DSA designation means for your advertising environment, we are happy to help.

 

Further reading:

10/06/2026, Dr. Anna Kellner, Helena Kasper, Moritz Mehner, Yannik Rothweiler

AI Flash: What AI start-ups could still clarify before their next review in light of Suno, LAION and the AI Act

Since this summer, several legal questions have become more tangible for AI start-ups. On 31 July 2026, the Munich Regional Court (Landgericht München I) held that the music generator Suno infringes copyright in works from GEMA’s repertoire (case no. 42 O 763/25, not yet final). On 3 September 2026, the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) heard the case concerning the creation of the LAION training dataset and intends to deliver its judgment on 17 December 2026 (case no. I ZR 281/25). The transparency obligations under Art. 50 AI Act have applied since 2 August 2026. Products placed on the market from 9 December 2026 are subject to new product liability rules that expressly cover software.

Such topics are therefore likely to come up in due diligence for a financing round, in a customer audit, in a procurement review by a large company or in an exit. We have compiled six questions that an AI start-up should ask itself in advance in order to be prepared for such reviews and negotiations.

 

Were the training data lawfully obtained and licensed?

In the Suno case, the Munich Regional Court did not apply the text and data mining exception in Section 44b of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) to the extent that works had been memorised in the model. According to the judgment, there was also no lawful access, because Suno had downloaded the works from YouTube by circumventing technical protection measures. In the LAION proceedings, the Federal Court of Justice has to decide, among other things, when a reservation of rights is machine-readable. Anyone training on third-party data might therefore be well advised to keep a traceable record of where the data come from and how they were accessed.

Helpful documentation: a register of data sources with access route, licences and terms of use, and documentation of how reservations of rights are observed.

 

Can the model reproduce protected content, and who is liable if it does?

In the Suno case, the court inferred from reproducible outputs that the works were stored in the model and treated this as reproduction under Section 16 UrhG. According to the judgment, simple, open-ended user prompts do not break the attribution to the provider; the position might be different for prompts that deliberately steer the output. The same chamber had already found copyright infringement in November 2025 in GEMA v OpenAI concerning song lyrics (judgment of 11 November 2025, case no. 42 O 14139/24). Whether the higher courts will follow is open. Until then, it might even make sense to test one’s own model specifically for such outputs and to document the results.

Helpful documentation: test logs on the reproduction of training content, a description of the output filters and a procedure for complaints from rights holders.

 

Does the company hold the rights to its code, data and model?

For employees, the economic rights in computer programs generally vest in the employer under Section 69b UrhG. This rule does not, however, apply to code written by founders before incorporation or to work by freelancers and agencies. Here it would need to be checked whether, and to what extent, rights of use were granted. Since a grant of rights is, in case of doubt, limited to the purpose of the contract (Section 31(5) UrhG), express provisions could avoid later doubts. Open-source components and open model weights may bring further licence conditions, for example on redistribution, purpose of use and attribution. Most commentators deny copyright protection for model weights as such; to our knowledge, the courts have not yet decided the question. Contracts and protection as trade secrets under the German Trade Secrets Act (GeschGehG), which requires appropriate confidentiality measures, are therefore likely to carry all the more weight.

Helpful documentation: founder and employment contracts with IP clauses, freelancer agreements, a list of open-source components and models with their licences, and a description of the confidentiality measures.

 

What role and which obligations does the company have under the AI Act?

The obligations depend on whether the company is a provider or a deployer, whether it develops or modifies a general-purpose AI model and which risk category its system falls into. Art. 50 has applied since 2 August 2026. Providers of generative systems placed on the market before that date must implement the machine-readable marking under Art. 50(2) by 2 December 2026. Following the Digital Omnibus, the obligations for high-risk systems under Annex III apply from 2 December 2027. Providers established outside the EU may also need to appoint an authorised representative in the Union: for general-purpose AI models already now (Art. 54), for high-risk systems under Annex III from December 2027 (Art. 22).

Helpful documentation: a classification of role and risk category, evidence of the marking and, where applicable, the technical documentation and the summary of training content.

 

Is the processing of personal data in training and operation secured?

If training data contain personal data, training requires a legal basis. Which one is available depends on where the data come from. For publicly available data, legitimate interests under Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR are likely to be the main option; the European Data Protection Board set out criteria for the balancing test in its Opinion 28/2024. Where the data come from the company’s own users, consent under point (a) or, again, legitimate interests may also be considered. The contract with the user under point (b) is likely to cover training only to the extent that it serves the service for that particular user, not the general improvement of the model. Consent can be withdrawn, and as things stand, individual data can hardly be removed from a trained model in a targeted way. In operation, the contract with the user can cover the processing to the extent that the AI service forms part of the contract. If the start-up processes data on behalf of its customers, the question of the legal basis lies primarily with them. If it also uses the same data for its own training, it pursues, according to a widely held view, a purpose of its own and to that extent acts outside the scope of processing on behalf of its customers.

Helpful documentation: records of processing activities with the legal bases chosen, depending on the basis a legitimate interests assessment or the consent texts, a data protection impact assessment and data processing agreements with clear rules on the use of customer data for training.

 

What do the contracts with customers and model providers provide, and what changes for liability from December?

Many AI products are built on a model from a large provider whose terms largely determine use, liability and changes unilaterally. It might be worth checking whether one’s own customer contracts fit these terms, for example regarding indemnities for infringements caused by outputs, liability caps and commitments on data use. Under Directive (EU) 2024/2853, manufacturers are strictly liable for products placed on the market from 9 December 2026, including defective software and AI systems. This liability cannot be excluded or limited by contract vis-à-vis injured persons. Between businesses, on the other hand, liability arrangements remain possible, for example for recourse within the supply chain. The German implementing act has not yet been adopted.

Helpful documentation: the model providers’ terms of use, template customer contracts and an overview of liability provisions and insurance.

The main open question is whether, on 17 December, the Federal Court of Justice will treat the creation of training datasets as covered by the text and data mining exception or refer questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union. This could determine how robust datasets based on publicly available content are. In a review, the key question is therefore likely to be whether a start-up knows its risks and can show how it deals with them, regardless of whether every legal question has been settled. Compiling the documents listed above now could pay off, also as a basis for negotiations on warranties and indemnities. We are happy to help with questions on individual points.

09/29/2026, Moritz Mehner, Yannik Rothweiler

EmpCo 2026: Section 15b UWG and Existing Stock

The decision has been made just days before the EmpCo rules take effect: On 24 September 2026, the German Bundestag adopted a new Section 15b of the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG). For certain goods already placed on the market before 27 September 2026, the new provision 

requires courts to take particular account of the principle of proportionality when assessing claims for injunctive relief relating to certain environmental claims and labels. However, the new rule does not introduce a general sell-off period.

The new EmpCo rules will apply from 27 September 2026. Until now, one of the key questions has been how to deal with goods that were already placed on the market before this date but may no longer comply with the new requirements.

The German legislator has now responded to this issue. As part of the modernisation of German design law, the Bundestag has adopted the new Section 15b UWG.

What does this mean for existing stock?

For certain EmpCo violations involving goods placed on the market before 27 September 2026, claims for injunctive relief will in future have to be assessed in accordance with the principles of good faith and proportionality.

The legislation specifically identifies four factors that are relevant to this assessment:

  • the severity of the infringement; 
  • the company's efforts to remedy the infringement;  
  • the costs associated with remedying the infringement; and 
  • the environmental impact that would result from the measures taken. 

The special provision is temporary and is scheduled to expire on 27 September 2028.

No general sell-off period

The new provision does not make an EmpCo violation automatically permissible and does not create a general transitional or sell-off period. However, it may provide significant flexibility in individual cases. According to the explanatory memorandum to the legislation, the balancing of interests may, depending on the circumstances, result in measures such as additional information requirements, a specific sell-off period for certain products, or even the exclusion of an injunctive claim altogether.

An important distinction is that the special provision does not apply generally to all goods produced before the cut-off date. It applies only to goods that had already been placed on the market before 27 September 2026.

What should companies do now?

For companies with potentially affected stock, documentation is becoming even more important. Companies should, in particular, document:

  • which goods are affected; 
  • when they were placed on the market; 
  • which corrective measures have already been taken or are still possible; and 
  • what costs and environmental impacts would result from those measures. 

For communications that can be changed quickly – such as websites, online shops or social media – the EmpCo deadline remains fully relevant. The new provision therefore does not eliminate the risk of legal disputes. It does, however, create additional arguments and potential defence options for companies.

For existing stock, the key question may therefore no longer be limited to: “Is the environmental claim permissible?”

It may also be: “Is the injunction being sought proportionate under the circumstances?”

EmpCo Compliance & Litigation

SKW Schwarz supports companies in implementing the new EmpCo requirements – from reviewing environmental and sustainability claims and addressing packaging and existing stock to defending companies against cease-and-desist claims, injunctive relief and regulatory fines.

More about our EmpCo Compliance & Litigation services  (LINK)

09/25/2026, Dr. Daniel Kendziur

Information Notice on Export Controls and Technology Transfer in Ukraine (Resolution No. 875)

With Resolution No. 875, Ukraine introduced a new procedure as of 1 July 2026 for the export of military goods, certain dual-use goods, and related technologies. The aim is to enable Ukrainian manufacturers to gain faster access to international markets while at the same time maintaining control over security-relevant technologies. The procedure applies for the duration of the currently prevailing martial law and for an additional six months thereafter.

This information notice provides an overview of the new export regime under Resolution No. 875, outlines the key requirements applicable to exporters and foreign importers, and explains why product classification, compliance structures, and contractual arrangements are essential prerequisites for resilient supply chains.

 

Which goods and business constellations are covered?

Resolution No. 875 covers military goods listed on Ukraine’s military goods list as well as certain dual-use goods and technologies. This is particularly relevant in practice for companies that develop, manufacture, or trade in UAV and UGV systems (unmanned aerial and ground vehicles) or related technologies. Both complete systems and components and individual parts are covered, provided that they are functionally associated with the respective system.

As a general rule, the new procedure requires the underlying export contract to have a value of at least UAH 15 million (approximately EUR 290,000). Individual parts or components may, however, also be covered at lower values if they are embedded in broader procurement or project structures.

The export regime is also limited to certain destination countries. Exports are only permitted to third countries that have concluded an agreement on military-technical or defence-industrial cooperation with Ukraine. This includes, for example, states that have concluded so-called “Drone Deals” with Ukraine. Six such “Drone Deals” have already been concluded for a period of 10 years. Numerous EU and NATO member states are expected to fall within the scope of these privileged third countries. For companies from these countries, the new regime generally opens up facilitated access to Ukrainian military goods and technologies, while at the same time creating a more closely regulated framework for technological and security-related cooperation.

 

Structure of the approval procedure and role of the authorities

Export licences are issued by the State Service of Export Control (SSECU). Decisions concerning goods that are not included on the list of “critical products” are to be issued within 30 days under a “fast-track” procedure. Such “critical products” are subject to stricter review, with a 90-day deadline. Defence and security authorities are involved in the decision-making process; if they do not provide their position within the statutory deadlines, a deemed approval mechanism applies.

For exporters, this means that, provided the application documents are complete and plausible, significantly shorter processing times can be expected. At the same time, there is increased pressure to prepare and document the application carefully, particularly with regard to the end-use and end-user, the customer structure, and the overall project architecture.

 

Shift of compliance responsibilities to companies

A significant part of the compliance review is shifted to the companies involved. Foreign importers and other customers must, in particular, ensure that they are not themselves subject to sanctions, are not controlled by an “aggressor state”, and do not have among their shareholders, beneficial owners, or executives any persons with links to such an aggressor state.

For exporters, this results in an increased need for structured review processes. The requirements typically go beyond conventional sanctions-list screening and also include an analysis of ownership and control structures as well as relevant business relationships. In practice, the Ukrainian authorities can be expected to require comprehensible documentation of these checks, and the corresponding processes will need to be integrated into standardised export control workflows.

 

Technology transfer, intellectual property and onward-transfer controls

Resolution No. 875 expressly permits the transfer of technologies, while retaining control over intellectual property and onward-transfer rights in Ukrainian hands:

  • As a general rule, only a right of use is to be granted; ownership of the intellectual property remains with the Ukrainian rights holder.
  • Any transfer, re-export, or other use beyond the purpose originally approved requires the prior consent of the competent Ukrainian authorities.
  • Technology transfer agreements must be structured in such a way that the allocation of rights (IP ownership vs. rights of use), the permitted purposes of use, and any onward-transfer rights are clearly defined and aligned with Ukrainian requirements.

For foreign companies, early involvement of IP and export control compliance functions is advisable. Already at the offer and contract stage, IP provisions, end-use clauses, and re-export restrictions should be reviewed and harmonised with the requirements of Resolution No. 875.

 

State guarantees of the importing state and assurance of end-use

For numerous exports – particularly in the case of sensitive military goods and technologies – state guarantees from the importing country are required. These  guarantees serve to

  • secure the end-use of the goods,
  • establish binding re-export restrictions, and
  • ensure compliance with the conditions governing the transfer of technology.

In practice, this means that exporters will regularly need to coordinate not only with the foreign customer but also with authorities in the importing country as part of a coordinated process. Contractual arrangements and project planning should therefore be designed to ensure that the relevant state end-use and guarantee letters are obtained in good time and integrated into the scheduling of delivery and payment milestones.

 

Fee structure and economic implications

The new export regime provides for significant value-based fees:

  • A fee of 20% of the value of the goods is payable for finished military and dual-use products as well as technology transfers.
  • For components and parts, the fee amounts to 30% of the value of the goods.
  • The fee is already due upon submission of the application; no refund is made if the export licence is refused.

In addition, a fee may also be incurred if products manufactured using Ukrainian technology are subsequently exported to third countries. Companies must factor the economic impact of these fees into their pricing and project calculations at an early stage and structure their payment arrangements accordingly. This includes, among other things, allocating the fee burden between the contracting parties, reflecting the fees in payment schedules, and taking potential approval risks into account in the contractual architecture.

 

Priority of Ukrainian procurement needs and project risks

Ukraine reserves the right to defer exports in favour of its own procurement needs. If there is a domestic defence requirement, export licences may be refused and licences that have already been issued may subsequently be suspended.

For companies, this means that even after an approval has been granted, a degree of uncertainty remains regarding the actual feasibility of the export. Long-term supply agreements should take this possibility into account contractually, particularly with regard to

  • delivery obligations and delivery deadlines,
  • liability provisions and warranty structures, as well as
  • force majeure or hardship clauses.

A clear allocation of risks between the parties is required in order to appropriately address approval risks and the possibility of government intervention.

 

Conclusion and recommendations for action

Companies wishing to benefit from the new export regime or already involved in the relevant supply chains should, as a first step, systematically assess and document

  • whether their products, components, or technologies are covered by the Ukrainian military goods list or the relevant dual-use areas,
  • whether the applicable value thresholds and destination countries (privileged third countries with cooperation agreements) are met, and
  • which project structures (end customers, intermediaries, technology transfers, licensing models) are envisaged.

On this basis, the following measures are particularly advisable:

  • adapting internal export control and compliance processes to the requirements of Resolution No. 875,
  • conducting an in-depth analysis of customer, ownership, and control structures in order to exclude sanctions exposure and links to aggressor states,
  • reviewing and restructuring technology transfer agreements, IP provisions, and end-use agreements in light of the Ukrainian requirements,
  • incorporating state end-use and guarantee letters into project planning and contractual arrangements, as well as
  • integrating the value-based fees and approval risks into pricing, financing, and project calculations.

We would be pleased to support you with the legal assessment of specific export and import projects, the structuring of contractual and compliance frameworks, and the strategic assessment of the new export regime under Resolution No. 875 in relation to your business models.

Dr. Oliver Hornung will be pleased to assist you with any questions or structuring matters relating to export controls and technology transfer in Ukraine.

09/24/2026, Dr. Oliver Hornung

Information Notice on the Bundeswehr Infrastructure Acceleration Act (BwIBG)

With the draft Bundeswehr Infrastructure Acceleration Act (Bundeswehr-Infrastrukturbeschleunigungsgesetz – BwIBG), the Federal Government is responding to the significantly increased need for the expansion of military infrastructure against the backdrop of the changed security and defence policy situation in Europe. The draft law aims to significantly accelerate the planning, approval and implementation of defence-related construction and infrastructure projects while ensuring the long-term operational reliability of military properties and facilities.

To this end, the BwIBG consolidates provisions in a separate Federal Military Construction Act (Bundeswehrbaugesetz – BwBauG) and introduces accompanying amendments, inter alia, to environmental, nature conservation, water and forestry law, the law governing restricted areas and land acquisition, the Code of Administrative Court Procedure and the Federal Administrative Services Act.

This information letter outlines the key provisions of the draft and assesses its practical implications, particularly for companies involved in Bundeswehr infrastructure projects or considering such involvement.

 

1. Federal Military Construction Act: New Framework for the Construction and Operation of Military Infrastructure

The core element of the BwIBGA major element of the planned reforms is the new Federal Military Construction Act (BwBauG). It defines its scope of application, regulates responsibilities for construction tasks and establishes key acceleration and prioritisation decisions.

Scope of application: The BwBauG applies to the planning and implementation of construction projects for the purposes of the Bundeswehr and allied armed forces, as well as to the operation of the relevant military properties and buildings. It therefore covers both new construction and expansion measures as well as the operation and adaptation of existing infrastructure, including the infrastructural preparations required for crises and defence situations.

Construction tasks and direct federal execution: In addition to the existing performance of construction tasks by the construction administrations of the Länder on behalf of the Federal Government under the principle of delegated federal administration (Organleihe) pursuant to Section 5b of the Financial Administration Act (FVG), the Federal Government is to be able to carry out its construction tasks directly in the future. The management, coordination and execution of construction tasks may be transferred to the Bundeswehr administration unless a Land assumes responsibility for the construction task under a procedure agreed in advance. This creates an additional channel alongside the traditional federal construction administrations, which is intended to increase implementation capacity, particularly for time-critical projects.

Corporate participation: The Federal Government is expressly to be authorised to establish a company under private law or to acquire an interest in such a company for the construction and operation of military infrastructure. This creates scope for project-specific corporate structures, for example for resilient energy and supply infrastructure at military sites, and enables greater involvement of private-sector expertise in planning, construction and operation.

A central policy decision concerns the classification of military infrastructure projects as projects in the overriding public interest. Pursuant to Section 4 BwBauG, the construction and operation of facilities for the purposes of the Bundeswehr and allied armed forces are deemed to be in the overriding public interest and to serve the security of the Federal Republic of Germany. Accordingly, defence interests are given particularly significant weight in balancing decisions, for example in planning approval or other approval proceedings; nevertheless, where several interests are considered to be in the overriding public interest, a case-by-case balancing of those interests remains necessary.

 

2. Acceleration of Proceedings: Legal Remedies and Concentration of Jurisdiction

The BwIBG provides for various instruments aimed at shortening proceedings and increasing planning certainty:

Legal remedies without suspensive effect: Pursuant to Section 3(1) BwBauG, legal remedies against the admissibility or implementation of construction projects under Section 1 BwBauG are generally not to have suspensive effect. This means that measures may initially continue despite pending lawsuits or objections. Effective legal protection remains available through interim proceedings and the decision on the merits; however, the threshold for bringing construction to an effective standstill is raised.

First and final instance jurisdiction of the Federal Administrative Court: Section 3(2) BwBauG provides for the concentration of administrative court jurisdiction in the Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht – BVerwG) for certain defence-related projects with a high degree of infrastructure and security relevance. This includes, inter alia, disputes concerning restricted-area orders and measures under the Restricted Areas Act, certain military transmission and supply infrastructure extending across Länder, permits and permit exemptions for military airfields, and designations under the Land Acquisition Act. In these cases, the BVerwG will have first and final instance jurisdiction. Multi-level judicial proceedings are thereby avoided, divergent decisions by different administrative courts are reduced and the duration of proceedings is shortened.

Consultation and recognition arrangements under water hazard law: Section 5 BwBauG authorises the Federal Ministry of Defence (BMVg) to designate and recognise, for its area of responsibility, its own expert organisation (e.g. the Bundeswehr Technical Inspection Authority) to carry out technical inspections under the Ordinance on Installations for the Handling of Substances Hazardous to Water. This strengthens in-house expertise, reduces reliance on external bodies and facilitates the crisis-resilient maintenance of critical supply infrastructure.

 

3. Environmental, Nature Conservation, Water and Forestry Law: Privileges and New Compensation Mechanisms

The draft does not provide for a general reduction of substantive environmental standards. Instead, it establishes specific procedural simplifications and priorities for defence purposes.

Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): For certain defence projects on defence areas or areas designated accordingly, the BMVg or a body designated by it may, on a temporary basis until the end of 2035, refrain from carrying out an EIA. In such cases, the examination of the requirements for an exemption and publication of the decision may be dispensed with if defence interests would otherwise be adversely affected, for example due to security classification requirements.

Immission control law: Material modifications to certain military installations where noise is the only factor triggering an amendment permit are to be eligible for processing under a simplified notification procedure in the future. Substantive protection requirements remain in place; the acceleration concerns the formal procedure.

Water law and drinking water protection: Military areas are only to be designated as drinking water protection areas for the first time if a local water supply cannot otherwise be provided at reasonable cost and effort. With regard to water protection and flood protection measures, it is clarified that the intended use of defence areas must generally be ensured, provided that key water-law protection objectives are not jeopardised.

Forestry law and military areas: Certain defence-related areas – such as cleared training grounds, sealed bunker areas or defined safety strips around military installations – will expressly no longer be considered forests within the meaning of the Federal Forest Act. In addition, Section 45 of the draft Federal Forest Act (BWaldG-E) gives priority to the intended use of areas serving, inter alia, defence purposes. Provisions of Land law, particularly those concerning forest planning, are only applicable to the extent that they do not impair military use.

Nature conservation law and compensation: The Federal Nature Conservation Act will permit, for certain military interventions on defence areas, a departure from conventional area-based compensatory and replacement measures: unavoidable impacts may be permissible until the end of 2035 if, instead, a compensatory payment is made in accordance with the Federal Compensation Ordinance. The compensatory payment is to be appropriately increased in comparison with other projects in the overriding public interest and is to be used for equivalent or higher-value ecological improvements in the affected or adjacent natural area. In addition, military use, the construction and operation of military installations, and certain hazard prevention and maintenance measures will be exempted from individual nature conservation prohibitions. In the future, the BMVg or the Bundeswehr will largely be responsible for exemptions and derogations under species protection law for defence-related projects; decisions will be taken in consultation with the competent nature conservation authorities.

 

4. Restricted Areas and Land Acquisition Acts: Early Safeguarding and Deadlines with Approval Fictions

The Restricted Areas Act and the Land Acquisition Act are being adapted to current requirements.

Restricted Areas Act: The purpose of defence will be defined broadly and expressly extended to include alliance obligations and international treaties. In future, the term “defence installation” will also include specifically planned installations and designated areas, allowing restricted areas to be established at an early planning stage. A three-month period, with the possibility of a one-time extension, will be introduced for consulting the Länder; once the deadline has expired, it will be presumed that there are no objections. In addition, decisions concerning structural and other installations within a restricted area will be placed more strongly under the responsibility of the restricted-area authority (BMVg or a designated body), combined with decision-making deadlines and a deemed-consent mechanism.

Land Acquisition Act: The consultation procedure for the Länder and municipalities in land acquisition measures will likewise be structured through deadlines with deemed approval. For properties already owned by the Federal Government that were previously used for military purposes and remain unused, a simplified designation and allocation procedure will be introduced, which, under certain conditions, makes it unnecessary to repeat the entire land acquisition procedure. At the same time, the extent to which the designation of a property for defence purposes restricts municipal planning autonomy will be clarified.

 

5. Implications for Companies and Other Stakeholders

For companies involved, or considering becoming involved, as service providers, contractors or project partners in Bundeswehr infrastructure projects, the draft BwIBG has several practical implications:

New cooperation and operating models: The express possibility for the Federal Government to establish or acquire interests in companies under private law for the construction and operation of military infrastructure creates scope for structured partnerships, for example in the context of energy, supply and operating concepts. Contractual arrangements, governance and risk allocation must take these public-law framework conditions into account.

Changed responsibilities and decision-making processes: The strengthened role of the Bundeswehr administration and the BMVg – including their own expert organisations and regulatory decision-making powers in nature conservation law – changes points of contact, decision-making processes and escalation paths in projects.

Accelerated procedures and legal-remedy framework: Deadlines with deemed-approval and deemed-consent mechanisms, the removal of the suspensive effect of legal remedies, and the first and final instance jurisdiction of the BVerwG result in faster but also more condensed proceedings. Companies must adapt their project planning, internal decision-making processes and compliance structures accordingly, as time windows will become tighter and legal risks will need to be addressed at an early stage.

A new balance in environmental, nature conservation and forestry law: While substantive standards remain in place, the weighting shifts in favour of defence-related projects. In practical project terms, this means different requirements for environmental and nature conservation concepts, a greater role for monetary compensation and the need to reconcile land and site decisions at an early stage with the specific privileges and restrictions.

 

Conclusion and Recommendations for Action

Once a consolidated or final version of the legislation is available, affected companies should systematically analyse their project portfolios to determine the extent to which they are affected by the new instruments, priorities and transfers of responsibility, and what adjustments may be required with regard to strategy, contractual arrangements, compliance structures and risk assessment.

Dr. Oliver Hornung will be pleased to answer any questions regarding this information letter on the Bundeswehr Infrastructure Acceleration Act.

09/24/2026, Dr. Oliver Hornung

How the Digital Interstate Media Treaty regulates media, platforms and AI

With the Digital Interstate Media Treaty (Digitale Medien-Staatsvertrag), the German states intend to adapt the Interstate Media Treaty (Medienstaatsvertrag, MStV) to new European requirements for digital media, political advertising and artificial intelligence. The draft of the first part (Ninth Interstate Media Amendment Treaty, version of 10 June 2026) mainly affects media companies, online platforms, providers of journalistic content and the state media authorities (Landesmedienanstalten) as supervisory authorities. The heads of government of the states approved the draft on 25 June 2026 and intend to sign it by January 2027 at the latest. It is scheduled to enter into force on 1 August 2027; if not all instruments of ratification have been deposited by 31 July 2027, it will become void.

The Interstate Media Treaty primarily contains the provisions required to give effect to the European Media Freedom Act (EMFA), the Regulation on the transparency and targeting of political advertising and the AI Act. The Regulations are, in principle, directly applicable; the Interstate Media Treaty mainly determines who monitors compliance with them. For companies, this means: new transparency, cooperation and compliance obligations meet extended supervisory powers of the state media authorities. For the first time, the draft also brings the press within the scope of the Interstate Media Treaty and defines what is to be regarded as a print product (Druckerzeugnis) and as a periodical print product (periodisches Druckerzeugnis) (Section 1(1) and (2), Section 2(2) nos. 32 and 33 MStV-E; MStV-E refers to the Interstate Media Treaty as amended by the draft).

 

New competences regarding AI

The state media authorities are given an express role as market surveillance authorities for AI applications in the media sector.

This competence builds on the federal AI Market Surveillance and Innovation Promotion Act (KI-Marktüberwachungs- und Innovationsförderungsgesetz, KI-MIG), which entered into force on 29 July 2026. Under Section 2(1) KI-MIG, the Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur) is the market surveillance authority for the AI Act unless the Act provides otherwise. Section 2(8) KI-MIG provides for an exception for media service providers within the meaning of Art. 2(2) EMFA that provide, take into service or use AI systems in operating, offering, distributing and making available media services for journalistic or advertising purposes. For these cases, the federal act leaves market surveillance to the authorities competent under the law of the states. In this area, the Federal Network Agency merely receives complaints and forwards them to the competent authority (Section 8 KI-MIG). The new Section 111(5) MStV-E builds on Section 2(8) KI-MIG and designates the state media authority competent under Section 106 MStV as the market surveillance authority.

The state media authorities are therefore competent only where two conditions are met. The first concerns the provider: only media service providers within the meaning of the EMFA are covered, i.e. providers whose professional activity is to provide a media service, who have editorial responsibility for the choice of the content and who determine the manner in which it is organised. These include private television and radio broadcasters, providers of on-demand services, press publishers, journalistic online services and the public service broadcasters. Online platforms are covered only where, exceptionally, they themselves have editorial responsibility for the choice of their content. Search engines do not fall within the EMFA definition, and providers of AI services such as chatbots are, as a rule, not media service providers because they lack editorial responsibility. For them, the Federal Network Agency remains the market surveillance authority; for general-purpose AI models, it is the European Commission’s AI Office. The second condition concerns the purpose: the AI system must be used for journalistic or advertising purposes. If a publisher uses AI e.g. in recruitment or accounting, the Federal Network Agency remains competent. Depending on the specific use cases, the same media company may therefore be subject to two supervisory authorities.

Section 111(5) MStV-E does not limit supervision to individual provisions of the AI Act. The state media authorities monitor all obligations incumbent on the media service provider as provider or deployer of an AI system; an earlier draft had limited their competence to the enforcement of Art. 50 AI Act. In practice, supervision will mainly concern the transparency obligations under Art. 50 AI Act. Anyone deploying AI to generate or manipulate image, audio or video content constituting a deep fake must disclose this; where the content forms part of an evidently artistic, satirical or fictional work, disclosure in an appropriate manner that does not hamper the display or enjoyment of the work is sufficient (Art. 50(4), first subparagraph, AI Act). The scope of the term “deep fake” is disputed. On 5 June 2026, the Broadcasting Commission of the states (Rundfunkkommission) criticised the broad interpretation in the European Commission’s draft guidelines on Art. 50 AI Act, arguing that press, audio and video content published under editorial responsibility would otherwise be subject to disproportionate labelling obligations. AI-generated text published with the purpose of informing the public on matters of public interest must also be disclosed. This obligation does not apply where the text has undergone a process of human review or editorial control and a person or company holds editorial responsibility for their publication (Art. 50(4), second subparagraph, AI Act). As a rule, the disclosure obligation therefore does not apply to texts published under editorial responsibility; the AI Act provides for no comparable exception for image, audio and video content. Where a media house operates its own AI applications, such as a chatbot on its website, the provider obligations under Art. 50(1) and (2) AI Act apply in addition: human beings must be informed that they are interacting with an AI system, and synthetic content must be marked in a machine-readable format.

Fines for infringements of the AI Act are imposed by the respective market surveillance authority (Section 17(1) KI-MIG), which will in future be the state media authority in the media sector. For infringements of Art. 50 AI Act, Art. 99(4) AI Act provides for administrative fines of up to EUR 15 million or up to 3 % of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higher. The state media authority may initiate proceedings against public broadcasters and against providers of periodical print products only after consulting the competent supervisory body or the German Press Council (Deutscher Presserat), respectively. Their opinion is binding, provided that the limits of the margin of appreciation have been observed (Section 111(6) MStV-E). For cooperation with the Federal Network Agency, the Digital Services Coordinator and the European Commission, the state media authorities appoint a joint representative.

The period until the Interstate Media Treaty enters into force remains unresolved. The transparency obligations under Art. 50 AI Act have applied since 2 August 2026. Since then, Section 2(8) KI-MIG has assigned market surveillance in the media sector to the authorities competent under the law of the states, but does not itself designate any authority; the Interstate Media Treaty is to designate the state media authorities only with effect from 1 August 2027. Supervision under the Interstate Media Treaty continues irrespective of this: on 14 July 2026, the Commission on Licensing and Supervision (ZAK) for the first time issued decisions against AI services of Google and Perplexity. However, the Interstate Media Treaty does not confer the powers of a market surveillance authority under the AI Act, since Section 109 MStV requires an infringement of the Interstate Media Treaty itself. Neither the KI-MIG nor the Interstate Media Treaty specifies which authority may pursue infringements of Art. 50 AI Act by media service providers until August 2027.

 

Competences and new sanctions under the EMFA

To enforce the European Media Freedom Act, the draft extends the catalogue of administrative offences. Infringements of certain obligations, for example relating to functionalities of online platforms, transparency information, dialogue procedures with media service providers or the visibility of media offerings on user interfaces, may be prosecuted as administrative offences (Section 115(1a) MStV-E). The fine may amount to up to EUR 1.5 million (Section 115(2) MStV-E); the limitation period for prosecution will in future expire only after 24 months instead of six months (Section 115(5) MStV-E).

These obligations include, for example, Art. 18 EMFA, which requires providers of very large online platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube to provide media service providers that have declared themselves as such to the platform with a statement of reasons before suspending the provision of their services in relation to that content or restricting its visibility because the content is incompatible with the platform’s terms and conditions, to give them the opportunity to reply, and to process and decide upon their complaints with priority. In addition, the state media authorities will also monitor compliance with Art. 20 EMFA, which, from 8 May 2027, requires manufacturers, developers and importers of devices and user interfaces controlling or managing access to and use of media services to enable users to change the settings, including the default settings, freely and easily, and to ensure that the visual identity of media service providers is clearly visible.

Art. 24 EMFA applies where a service operates an audience measurement system, for example where data on usage, reach, views, viewing time, interaction or target groups are collected and processed for decisions on advertising, pricing, purchases and sales, planning or distribution. Art. 24 EMFA requires audience measurement methodologies that are transparent, impartial, inclusive, proportionate, non-discriminatory, comparable and verifiable. Providers of proprietary audience measurement systems must, in addition, disclose their methodology, have it audited annually by an independent body and, upon request, provide media service providers with the audience measurement data relating to their offering, including non-aggregated data.

Another focus of the new Digital Interstate Media Treaty is transparency of ownership and shareholding structures in the media sector. The Commission on Concentration in the Media (KEK) is to maintain a publicly accessible and regularly updated database (Section 60(8) MStV-E). It is to contain, in particular, information on the owners and shareholdings of relevant media companies. This is intended to make it easier to understand who is behind a media offering and which economic interconnections exist. 

 

Political advertising under supervision

The draft allocates competences for the new EU Regulation on the transparency and targeting of political advertising. In future, the state media authorities are to monitor the obligations under Arts. 11 and 12 of the Regulation in respect of telemedia providers, and the obligations under Arts. 5, 7 to 17 and 21 in respect of media service providers and of telemedia providers that are not intermediary services within the meaning of the Digital Services Act (Section 111(4) MStV-E). This covers, in particular, requirements relating to the labelling, transparency and delivery of political advertising. Infringements are to be sanctioned under the federal Political Advertising Transparency Act (Politische-Werbung-Transparenz-Gesetz), which is still in the parliamentary process (Section 115(1b) MStV-E). 

 

AI-supported media supervision

Of particular practical relevance is the newly proposed express legal basis for the use of technical means in media supervision (Section 109a MStV-E). In future, the state media authorities may use automated systems that check text, image, audio and video content for possible infringements. This may also include content that is not freely accessible. The use of such systems is intended, among other things, to detect infringements of media law and youth protection in the media. 

At the same time, the draft contains safeguards: a possible infringement detected automatically must be reviewed by a human being without undue delay. If the suspicion is not confirmed, the personal data processed must be deleted; if no review takes place, they must be deleted after 30 days at the latest. Data required for supervisory proceedings after a suspicion has been confirmed are subject to strict purpose limitation and must be deleted after six months at the latest, unless supervisory proceedings are pending by then. In supervisory proceedings, the provider concerned must be informed that technical means were used. 

Online platforms may also be required to provide the state media authorities with suitable technical interfaces, insofar as this is technically and economically reasonable. The details are to be specified by the state media authorities in joint statutes; the main results of the use of technical means are to be reported annually. 

 

Competences at a glance

Area of regulationState media authoritiesFederal Network Agency and other bodies
AI Act: media service providers using AI for journalistic or advertising purposes

Market surveillance and fines once the Interstate Media Treaty enters into force (Section 111(5) MStV-E, Sections 2(8) and 17(1) KI-MIG)

 

Federal Network Agency only as complaints body (Section 8 KI-MIG)
AI Act: all other uses of AI, including in media houses (e.g. HR, accounting)–

Federal Network Agency (Section 2(1) KI-MIG); sectoral authorities such as the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin)

 

General-purpose AI models

 

–AI Office of the European Commission

EMFA: Art. 18 (very large online platforms), Art. 20 (user interfaces), Art. 24 (audience measurement)

 

Supervision and fines (Section 115(1a) MStV-E)–
Political advertising (Regulation (EU) 2024/900)Arts. 11 and 12 for telemedia; Arts. 5, 7 to 17 and 21 for media service providers and for telemedia that are not intermediary services (Section 111(4) MStV-E)

Federal authorities under the Political Advertising Transparency Act, in particular for intermediary services (legislative procedure ongoing)

 

Interstate Media Treaty, including in respect of AI search and chatbotsSupervision under Sections 104 et seq. MStV (law already in force)–

 

What the draft means for media services

Overall, the draft extends media regulation further into the digital space. Media houses, platform operators and advertising marketers have to prepare for new transparency, organisational and documentation obligations for their services, advertising processes and AI applications. In parallel, the states are deliberating on a second part of the Interstate Media Treaty. According to press reports, it is intended, among other things, to make providers of AI information systems responsible for the content they generate; no consultation draft has been published so far. It also remains unclear how such responsibility relates to the liability rules of the Digital Services Act where AI answers are integrated into search engines and platforms.

09/22/2026, Moritz Mehner, Dr. Anna Kellner

EmpCo: Special rule planned in Germany for certain existing stock – what companies need to know now

Just days before the new EmpCo rules take effect, an important amendment to the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG) is taking shape. A special rule is planned for certain goods that were placed on the market before 27 September 2026. However, the proposed amendment would not introduce a general sell-through or grace period. For companies, the key priorities now are to document, prioritise and prepare for potential disputes.

On 27 September 2026, the new rules implementing the Empowering Consumers Directive (EmpCo) will take effect under the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG). From that date, environmental and sustainability communications will have to comply with stricter requirements.

One question is particularly pressing for companies: What happens to goods that are already on the market where the packaging contains environmental or sustainability claims that may no longer comply with the new requirements?

So far, the UWG does not provide for a general transition, grace or sell-through period for such goods. Just days before the deadline, however, an important amendment is now taking shape.

Proposed Section 15b UWG: proportionality test for claims for injunctive relief

According to a draft legislative resolution currently available, a new Section 15b UWG is to be introduced into German law.

Under the proposed provision, claims for injunctive relief based on certain EmpCo infringements relating to goods placed on the market before 27 September 2026 would have to be asserted in good faith and in accordance with the principle of proportionality.

As part of a comprehensive balancing of interests, four factors in particular would have to be taken into account:

  1. the seriousness of the infringement; 
  2. the efforts made by the company to remedy the infringement; 
  3. the costs associated with remedying the infringement; and 
  4. the environmental impact associated with remedying the infringement. 

The German Bundestag is expected to vote on the Act to Modernise Design Law on 24 September 2026, in the context of which the amendment to the UWG is, according to the information currently available, expected to be introduced. The proposed new provision has not yet been adopted.

No general sell-through or grace period

For companies, it is important to understand what the proposed rule would not do: based on the wording currently available, it would not introduce a general transition, grace or sell-through period.

Section 15b UWG-E would not automatically make an EmpCo infringement lawful. Instead, the provision is intended to make the enforcement of claims for injunctive relief in relation to certain goods already placed on the market subject to a proportionality test.

In a specific dispute, it could therefore be relevant, for example, whether a contested claim can be corrected by applying stickers or relabelling, what costs this would entail, or whether an immediate stop to distribution would result in the destruction of significant quantities of goods and the associated environmental impact.

Depending on the individual case, this balancing of interests may affect the nature and scope of injunctive relief. How the provision will be applied in practice, however, is likely to become clear only over time and, potentially, through case law.

Key distinction: “placed on the market” does not mean “produced”

One detail of the proposed wording is particularly important.

The special rule would not apply across the board to all goods produced before the deadline. Instead, it expressly refers to goods that were already placed on the market before 27 September 2026.

Companies holding significant quantities of goods or packaging should therefore carefully assess which inventory may fall within the scope of the proposed provision.

In particular, companies should now ensure that they can document when the relevant goods were placed on the market.

What companies should document now

The proposed rule makes documentation even more important. The information companies record today may later prove crucial when assessing whether injunctive relief is proportionate.

Companies should document in particular:

  • Which goods are affected? Which products or packaging contain potentially problematic environmental or sustainability claims? 
  • When were they placed on the market? Delivery records, inventory management data and other relevant evidence should be secured without delay. 
  • What measures have already been taken? For example, changes to future packaging, relabelling, stickers or information provided to retailers and other distribution partners. 
  • What further adjustments are possible? And what organisational and economic effort would they require? 
  • What costs would arise? For example, from relabelling, product recalls, changes to production or, where applicable, destruction of goods.  
  • What would the environmental impact be? This may be particularly relevant where significant quantities of goods or packaging would otherwise have to be destroyed. 

The latter four aspects in particular directly reflect the criteria that, according to the draft currently available, are to be considered as part of the proportionality assessment.

No extension for websites, online shops or social media

The proposed special rule should not be understood as a general extension of the EmpCo implementation deadline.

Based on the wording currently available, Section 15b UWG-E expressly refers to goods placed on the market before the deadline. Other forms of environmental and sustainability communication would not generally benefit from the proposed rule.

Companies should therefore continue to review and, where necessary, adapt websites, online shops, social media communications, digital campaigns and other communications that can be changed at short notice by 27 September.

EmpCo remains a litigation issue

The proposed amendment does not eliminate the risk of legal disputes.

Competitors, associations and qualified entities can take action against unlawful environmental and sustainability communications. The new provision would instead add another question to potential disputes: Is the claim for injunctive relief sought proportionate in the circumstances of the individual case?

In addition to the legal assessment of the claim itself, it may therefore become crucial how well a company has documented its existing inventory, the remedial measures already taken and the associated costs and environmental impact.

Companies should use the remaining days to focus on two areas:

1. Compliance:
Prioritise communications that can still be changed, review claims and secure the necessary supporting evidence.

2. Litigation readiness:
Document affected inventory and when it was placed on the market, assess potential remedial measures and record their economic and environmental impact.

What happens next?

The German Bundestag is expected to vote on the Act to Modernise Design Law on 24 September 2026. It remains to be seen whether the proposed Section 15b UWG will be adopted and, if so, in what final form.

For companies, the message is clear: Monitor developments – but do not wait for them.

The EmpCo deadline remains 27 September 2026. The proposed special rule could provide new arguments in the defence against claims for injunctive relief in relation to certain goods already placed on the market. However, it does not replace the need to review existing claims or to prepare for potential legal disputes.

Prioritise claims. Secure evidence. Document existing stock. Prepare for potential disputes.

EmpCo Compliance & Litigation

SKW Schwarz supports companies in implementing the new EmpCo requirements – from our EmpCo Quick Check and the legal review of environmental and sustainability claims to dealing with packaging and existing stock, as well as defending against cease-and-desist demands, claims for injunctive relief and regulatory fine proceedings.

Find out more about our EmpCo Compliance & Litigation services Click here

 

09/22/2026, Dr. Daniel Kendziur

KI-Flash: Advertising Law and Data Protection as Ads Launch in ChatGPT

Since August 24, 2026, German ChatGPT users have also been seeing ads.

OpenAI has opened the advertising channel for 31 European markets. For users on the free Free and Go plans, ChatGPT’s functions are now available only with ads, while the Plus, Pro, Business, Enterprise and Edu plans remain ad-free according to the provider’s announcement of 18 August 2026. Ads are also shown only to logged-in users who have reached the age of majority.

One week later, on 31 August 2026, OpenAI opened self-service access through the Ads Manager for the same markets in a beta version. Advertisers based in Germany have since been able to book ads without an agency or technology partner. Booking through the provider’s ads solutions team and through agency and technology partners remains available alongside this.

Ad-funded generative AI is therefore no longer an announced plan in the German market but live operation. This article sets out the standards of review under advertising and data protection law. It is addressed to companies that advertise in this environment or deploy AI assistants in their own operations; the provider’s own obligations are described only to the extent that they matter from that perspective. No statements by the competent authorities on this advertising model are available so far. 

This article opens a three-part series on current developments around AI assistants. The second part deals with the designation of ChatGPT as a very large online search engine under the Digital Services Act and the obligations attached to it. The third part asks to what extent advertisers and agencies are responsible for the content of ads placed in AI assistants and liable for the statements they make. The question of when a provider must have AI answers attributed to it as its own content was already covered in our KI-Flash of 2 July 2026.

 

No personalised advertising in the EEA so far

For ads on online platforms, a distinction is drawn between personalised and non-personalised advertising. The legal requirements for the two differ considerably. 

In the first phase, currently implemented in the European Economic Area, ads are selected without personalisation in the sense of profiling. What is used is the topic of the ongoing conversation together with limited contextual information such as approximate location, language, time of day and device type. Earlier chats and stored information are expressly excluded according to the provider. Advertisers receive aggregated performance data only, and no conversation content, no real names and no precise location data.

Personalised advertising requires separate consent. Only then do chat history, stored information and a user’s behaviour in response to earlier ads feed into the selection. Users’ consent is required for this, as OpenAI also expressly describes in the version of its European privacy policy of 2 June 2026. This personalised advertising option has not yet been activated in the EEA.

One point that has largely gone unnoticed deserves attention here: behaviour in response to earlier ads can only feed into the selection if it has been collected beforehand, and, at least according to the provider, that does not happen in the first phase. The change therefore does not consist solely in evaluating existing data but first of all in building up a new set of data. Consent would have to cover that step as well.

 

How must advertising in an AI assistant be labelled?

The provider describes the ads as clearly labelled and visually separated from the answer. Under advertising law, the question is usually discussed under Section 5a(4) UWG. No. 11 of the Annex to Section 3(3) UWG may also apply, which covers the use of editorial content financed by a trader and disguised as information. That provision presupposes, however, that editorial content exists at all, and whether an AI-generated answer qualifies is an open question. For comparison portals and search engines, editorial content is in part affirmed even though there is no editorial team in the traditional sense. What speaks against that classification is precisely the position taken by the ZAK, the joint commission of the German state media authorities, according to which AI answers are the provider’s own content and therefore do not appear as neutral reporting. Added to this are Section 6(1) DDG for commercial communication in digital services and, where the service qualifies as a media intermediary or a media-like offering, Section 22 MStV. Classification as a media intermediary depends on whether the service aggregates third-party content, selects it and determines how easily it can be found. That is exactly what the ZAK relied on in relation to source citations and link lists. A service that generates only its own answers does not meet that test.

The structural risk, however, lies not in the design of the ad block but in the selection logic. An ad selected on the basis of the topic of the ongoing conversation appears at a moment when the user has just articulated a specific concern. In functional terms it works like native advertising, even where it is presented as “formally separated”. Whether a visual separation is enough to address this problem of contextual proximity is a question of the specific implementation. 

 

Are AI answers the provider’s own content?

Against the labelling obligations under Section 22 MStV and Section 6 DDG it could be argued that a chat interface has no editorial part from which advertising would have to be distinguished in the first place. On the line that has emerged so far, that defence does not hold: in its judgment of 28 May 2026 (26 O 869/26), the Regional Court of Munich I treated a search engine’s “AI Overview” function as the provider’s own substantive statement and found that the provider had adopted the content as its own (paras. 33 f.). Three aspects were decisive: the function produces a self-contained running text that summarises, structures and evaluates search results; it forms statements that are not contained in the sources relied on; and, from the perspective of a reasonably informed average user, it appears as an answer for which the provider is responsible rather than as a neutral list of results. On 14 July 2026, in proceedings of the Hamburg/Schleswig-Holstein and Berlin-Brandenburg state media authorities, the ZAK issued its first orders against AI services operated by Google and Perplexity, holding that AI answers are the providers’ own content and that the liability exemption under the DSA does not apply. Neither decision is final and binding yet, and appeals have been announced. For Section 5a(4) UWG this preliminary question is irrelevant. For No. 11 of the Annex it matters, because editorial content is a constituent element there.

 

The promise about the answers

OpenAI promotes the principle that advertising does not influence the answers. Beyond being a product description, this also appears to be a statement about a material characteristic of the service within the meaning of Section 5 UWG. If the actual design departs from it – for instance through influence on ordering, product mentions or shopping integration – a misleading commercial practice would come into consideration. In practice the question of evidence arises immediately: how does a competitor prove a distortion in the model’s behaviour? How the model works lies solely within the provider’s sphere, which speaks in favour of a secondary burden of substantiation: the competitor puts forward tangible indications and the provider then has to respond in substantiated form. It can be countered that a secondary burden of substantiation is ruled out to the extent that the competitor can test the answering behaviour itself. Starting points are offered by the audit obligations under Art. 37, the ad repository under Art. 39 and researcher access under Art. 40 DSA – provisions that now apply as a result of the designation as a very large online search engine of 31 August 2026. More on this in the next article.

 

Who is subject to the consent requirement?

Section 25 TDDDG applies to access to information on terminal equipment through cookies. The OpenAI measurement pixel sets a first-party cookie on the advertiser’s domain. The consent requirement therefore falls not on the platform operator but on the booking party. The provider also makes a server-side interface for conversion measurement available; its use, too, is processing carried out by the booking party itself. 

Section 25 TDDDG does not apply to server-side transmission, because no access to terminal equipment takes place there. The only benchmark in that respect is the GDPR.

 

May chat histories be used to select ads?

This is where the real point of examination lies. Chats are shared for the purpose of completing a task, not for optimising advertising. Drawing on the history for ad selection must therefore be measured against Art. 5(1)(b) and Art. 6(4) GDPR, regardless of whether consent is obtained.

Art. 9 GDPR also comes into play. Conversation histories regularly reveal health data, religious or philosophical beliefs, sexual orientation or political opinions. In Cases C-252/21 and C-446/21 the CJEU applied a broad standard for when special categories of data are involved and set strict requirements for the validity of consent. In Case C-446/21 it also found a breach of the data minimisation principle because personal data had been processed for targeted advertising purposes without any distinction according to their nature. Irrespective of this, Art. 21(2) GDPR provides an unconditional right to object to direct marketing, which is not open to any balancing exercise. The right attaches solely to the purpose of the processing and not to the legal basis. It therefore also covers the delivery of non-personalised ads to the extent that these constitute direct marketing.

 

Self-commitment does not replace a legal basis

The provider has set category exclusions for physical health, mental health and politics; political advertising is currently not permitted at all. Exclusions of this kind are contractual self-commitments. They replace neither a legal basis under Art. 9 GDPR nor an assessment of sector-specific advertising bans. How a prohibition under the law on advertising for medicinal products is to be enforced in an interface in which users are describing their symptoms is an open question. 

The reverse case also arises. Under the provider’s advertising policies, regulated industries, among them legal, health and financial services, are excluded from booking outside the United States. For companies in these sectors, the first question is therefore not one of admissibility but one of access.

The protection of minors, too, operates through a technical self-commitment: ads are not served where the user is presumed to be a minor, as determined by age estimation. That protective measure is itself processing that calls for justification. Section 6 JMStV and No. 28 of the Annex to Section 3(3) UWG have to be taken into account in addition. Section 6 JMStV is a rule governing market conduct within the meaning of Section 3a UWG and can therefore also be enforced under unfair competition law. No. 28 of the Annex covers direct exhortations to children to buy, that is to persons under the age of fourteen. Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR comes into consideration as the legal basis for age estimation. It cannot be based on Art. 6(1)(c) GDPR to the extent that it rests on a voluntary self-commitment rather than on a specific legal obligation.

 

Transparency and labelling

The information obligations under Art. 12 to 14 GDPR are under particular scrutiny in 2026: on 19 March 2026 the EDPB launched a coordinated enforcement action on precisely these provisions, with 25 supervisory authorities taking part. A privacy policy revised shortly beforehand, which for the first time includes advertising as a processing purpose, therefore falls within an ongoing year of review.

Art. 50 AI Act has applied since 2 August 2026 in addition. Digital Omnibus Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 postponed only the machine-readable marking under Art. 50(2) AI Act for systems placed on the market before that date, namely to 2 December 2026. As regards competence, a distinction has to be drawn in Germany: under the KI-MIG, the Federal Network Agency is the central market surveillance authority, but for media services used for journalistic or advertising purposes competence remains, pursuant to Section 2(8) KI-MIG, with the authorities designated under state law.

 

What remains open for the booking party

What remains unresolved above all is which labelling obligations apply to the booking party itself, independently of how the platform operator implements them, and who is the controller under data protection law once the booking party deploys its own measurement tools. The third article in this series addresses both questions. For companies whose staff use ad-funded plans in their day-to-day work, there is the added point that conversation content feeds into ad selection there. What this means for trade secrets and for professionals bound by professional secrecy has barely been examined so far.

We would be glad to support you in reviewing your campaigns in the AI environment, in designing labelling and measurement, and in assessing the allocation of roles under data protection law.

Further reading:

09/21/2026, Helena Kasper, Moritz Mehner, Yannik Rothweiler

The New EU FDI Screening Regulation – What Companies Should Consider Now

At the beginning of 2026, the European Commission, the Council of the European Union, and the European Parliament reached an agreement on the reform of the European Investment Control Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2019/452). However, the new regulation (EU) 2026/1386, known as the "EU Screening Regulation 2026," will primarily take effect from 2028. Nevertheless, it is advisable for companies to assess the implications of this regulation now and to take early action.

 

When Do the New Rules Take Effect?

The timing of the new rules is particularly significant for companies. The EU Screening Regulation 2026 was published on June 26, 2026, and will come into force on July 16, 2026. After an 18-month transition period, it will apply directly from January 17, 2028. By this date, all EU member states must have investment screening mechanisms that meet at least the requirements set forth in the regulation.

Germany will incorporate these regulations into a standalone Investment Screening Act (IPG), which will consolidate and systematize the existing regulations currently spread across the Foreign Trade Act (AWG) and the Foreign Trade Regulation (AWV). This should facilitate the examination of approval or notification requirements for companies in the future. The IPG is expected to be initiated "in a timely manner" according to previous announcements.

 

What Changes Are Fundamental in the EU?

The most significant structural change is the requirement for all member states to establish an investment screening regime. While the previous regulation allowed member states to decide whether to control foreign investments, the reform now mandates minimum harmonization. The era in which certain countries deliberately opted out of FDI screening, thus providing more attractive "hubs" for foreign investors, is over.

The regulation also establishes a common minimum catalog of sectors that must undergo prior screening for foreign investments and cannot be executed without approval. This includes companies developing, manufacturing, or marketing dual-use goods as defined by the EU Dual-Use Regulation, companies involved with goods or technologies listed on the EU Military Goods List, and companies in particularly sensitive technology sectors such as semiconductors, quantum technology, or certain forms of artificial intelligence. Additionally, operators of critical energy, transport, and digital infrastructure, companies exploring, extracting, processing, or stockpiling strategic raw materials, central financial market infrastructures, and operators of specific systems for conducting and evaluating elections are included.

The regulation introduces a two-stage review process modeled after merger control practices. In the first phase, the competent authority must decide within 45 days of a complete application whether to approve the investment or require a more in-depth review. This standardizes the often heterogeneous duration of the initial review phase across member states. Although the regulation does not set a binding deadline for the second phase, it remains at the discretion of the member states. However, the clearly defined first phase provides companies with greater planning certainty for short-term deal timing.

Another key point is the possibility of ex officio reviews. Even investments that are not subject to reporting can be reviewed within a period of up to five years, depending on the nature of the acquisition, if there are indications of potential impacts on security or public order. This existing regulation in Germany means that even seemingly "small" or "low-risk" transactions will not completely escape the authorities' scrutiny.

The substantive review criteria will also be tightened. While the review standard remains formally unchanged-focusing on potential negative impacts on security and public order-the regulation adds a detailed list of protected goods and investor-related factors that must be considered.

Finally, the cooperation mechanism within the EU will be reformed. The number of cases required to be reported and commented on will be reduced and focused on particularly critical investments. Simultaneously, the accountability of member states will increase: they will now have to explain to the Commission and other states to what extent they have considered opinions and comments and why they may have made different decisions. This increases the likelihood that investment decisions in one member state will also be made under the scrutiny of other states and the Commission.

Additionally, the establishment of a European database is planned to track whether and what measures have been taken against foreign investors.

 

What Does the Reform Mean for German Companies?

Germany is among the member states that have had an extensive investment screening regime for many years. From the perspective of German companies, the new EU regulation is not a completely new instrument but rather a tightening and structuring of what is already established practice.

The German investment review already covers both direct and indirect acquisitions, including investments through EU companies controlled by non-EU entities. Therefore, the explicit inclusion of indirect investments at the EU level is more of a confirmation than a disruption for Germany. The two-stage review process-preliminary review and formal review-is already standard practice in Germany.

Nonetheless, German companies will experience significant changes. Firstly, there will be a comprehensive assessment of all dual-use goods and goods listed in the EU Common Military List, ensuring that security-relevant products and technologies are systematically included in the review. Secondly, the scope of artificial intelligence will explicitly extend to defense and aerospace-appropriate AI systems; simultaneously, the definition of AI will be aligned with the provisions of the EU AI Act to ensure uniform and contemporary regulation. Furthermore, critical infrastructures will be mandatorily considered, particularly in the areas of transport, digital infrastructure, financial services, and election infrastructure, to adequately reflect the sensitivity of these sectors. Finally, the list of critical raw materials will be expanded to better account for supply security and the strategic importance of these materials within the investment review.

A central change also concerns the previous privileging of certain third countries. In the German investment review, investors from EFTA states like Switzerland or Norway were partially treated as EU investors and thus privileged in sensitive areas. The EU Screening Regulation 2026 prohibits discriminatory differences between third countries. For German companies with EFTA investors, this means that transactions previously considered "quasi EU-internal" will now fall fully under the scope of third-country investment control.

The procedural deadlines will also change. The first review phase currently lasts two months under German law; at the EU level, a uniform period of 45 days is now established.

Importantly, the information requirements for applications will be expanded. The documents and information previously specified in a general decree will not suffice to cover all the information required under the cooperation mechanism. Companies will now be expected to disclose their corporate structure in detail, describe activities in other member states, identify participations in EU projects of particular interest, and specify larger EU grants received in the past. Transparency in ownership and control structures will be particularly important: the more complex and opaque a structure is, the more likely authorities will view it as a risk indicator.

 

What Should Companies Do Now?

For companies, the reform means that they can no longer treat investment control as a "post-factum specialty" but must integrate it into their governance and transaction processes. They need to identify early on whether and to what extent they are active in any of the sectors that will be particularly sensitive in the future. This requires a detailed analysis of products, technologies, raw materials, and infrastructure functions. Particularly for dual-use goods, it is insufficient to consider only classic export goods; research, development, and pure marketing activities may also fall within the scope of application.

Simultaneously, companies should critically review their investor and ownership structures. Open questions regarding economic entitlement, potential state influences, or connections to sanctioned or high-risk jurisdictions should be clarified early on. The better these structures are documented and transparent, the lower the risk that they will be perceived as a risk factor in the review.

Additionally, it is advisable to clearly define internal responsibilities. Investment control is not solely a legal issue; it touches on strategy, finance, compliance, IT, and sometimes public policy. Companies are well advised to designate fixed points of contact, establish processes for the preparation and coordination of applications, and harmonize interfaces with other regulatory areas-particularly antitrust law, export controls, and sanctions law. Where complex international transactions are planned, a central "FDI Taskforce" can help synchronize different review regimes and deadlines, thereby avoiding delays.

Finally, German companies should closely monitor the development of the Investment Screening Act. It will be crucial to see how the German legislator implements the EU minimum catalog in detail, whether additional sectors will be voluntarily included, and how threshold values and review standards will be defined. Industries that are mentioned in the regulation as protected goods but not as mandatory review segments-such as manufacturers of critical pharmaceuticals or certain media companies-will have a particular interest in the specific national implementation.

09/21/2026, Maria Rothämel

AI Flash: AI literacy Under Article 4 of the AI Act: A Look at the New (Old) Questions

Following our report on the GEMA v. Suno case in our last AI Flash, we would like to continue providing you with regular legal insights into current developments in AI law.

 

Today’s topic: AI literacy under Article 4 of the AI Act

Hardly any provision of the AI Regulation affects as many companies in practice as Article 4 of the AI Act on so-called “AI literacy.” It applies regardless of risk class or industry and thus to anyone who offers or operates AI systems. This is already relevant simply when using ChatGPT, Copilot, or comparable tools in everyday work. The provision has now been amended by the Digital Omnibus on AI (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 of July 8, 2026, in effect since July 27, 2026). This is reason enough to take another detailed look at the regulation.

 

I. What Has Changed?

In its original version, Article 4 of the Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 June 2024 laying down harmonised rules on artificial intelligence  (AI Act) required providers and operators to ensure, to the best of their ability, that their personnel possessed a sufficient level of AI literacy. This wording faced criticism for implying a success that companies could hardly guarantee reliably.

The Digital Omnibus on AI has made adjustments. Article 4 AI Act now states:

(1) Providers and deployers of AI systems shall take measures to support the development of AI literacy of their staff and other persons dealing with the operation and use of AI systems on their behalf, taking into account their technical knowledge, experience, education and training and the context the AI systems are to be used in, and considering the persons or groups of persons on whom the AI systems are to be used. This obligation does not require providers or deployers to guarantee any specific level of AI literacy of any individual.

(2) The Commission and the Member States shall support and facilitate the efforts of providers and deployers of AI systems, in particular SMEs, in fulfilling their obligation under paragraph 1 of this Article. For that purpose, the Commission shall publish practical examples of how to comply with that obligation on the single information platform referred to in Article 62(3), point (b).

(3) The Board shall adopt recommendations, taking into account European competence frameworks, to support the Commission and Member States in the promotion of AI literacy required under paragraph 1, including by setting out common objectives.

Thus, the obligation has shifted from "ensuring" a level of competence to supporting the development of AI literacy through appropriate measures - explicitly without guaranteeing a specific individual competence level. 

Notably, what was not included in the new version of the regulation is significant: the original Commission proposal aimed to largely shift the responsibility for promoting AI literacy to the EU and the Member States. This fundamental realignment did not prevail in the trilogue. The obligation remains-albeit mitigated-with the providers and operators themselves. The only new aspect is the accompanying support from the Commission, Member States, and the AI Committee (paragraphs 2 and 3).

 

II. What Does "AI literacy" Actually Mean?

The term "AI literacy" is not defined in Article 4 AI Act but is elaborated in the definition provided in Article 3 No. 56 AI Act. According to this, AI literacy refers to the "skills, knowledge and understanding that allow providers, deployers and affected persons, taking into account their respective rights and obligations in the context of this Regulation, to make an informed deployment of AI systems, as well as to gain awareness about the opportunities and risks of AI and possible harm it can cause."

Thus, AI literacy is not merely technical niche knowledge but a bundle of technical understanding, risk awareness, and legal and ethical basic understanding. It addresses all actors along the AI value chain - from developers and operational staff to individuals who use AI systems on behalf of the company, such as external service providers.

Importantly for practice: Article 4 AI Act does not prescribe a specific training format, certification, or a dedicated "AI Officer." Internal training, e-learning, workshops, or external training are all permissible-what matters is that the measures fit the technical knowledge level, experience, context of use, and risk profile of the respective target group. Both the Federal Network Agency and the AI Service Center Austria of the RTR explicitly recommend documenting the measures taken (type of training, content, timing, affected groups) to demonstrate compliance with Article 4 AI Act if necessary, even though no legally mandated proof standard currently exists.

 

III. The (Highly Problematic) Question of Sanctions

The question remains, particularly contentious in practice: What happens if a company fails to promote AI literacy?

1. No Immediate Fine Under Article 99 AI Act

First, the good news: Article 99 AI Act lists the provisions subject to fines exhaustively. Article 4 AI Act is not mentioned there. Therefore, the regulation does not provide for an immediate fine specifically for violations of the AI literacy obligation - this is confirmed by both the Austrian AI Service Center of the RTR and the Federal Network Agency.

However, a violation is not without consequences. Some literature suggests that national market surveillance authorities - in Germany, the Federal Network Agency - can address violations of Article 4 AI Act based on national regulations with other enforcement measures. Moreover, and practically more significant, Article 4 AI Act exerts its effect mainly indirectly, through general civil and corporate law.

2. Employer Liability Under § 278 BGB

If a company uses AI systems, it bears the entrepreneurial risk as an operator and is responsible for the proper organization of operations and work equipment. If damage occurs to customers or business partners - due to incorrect operation of an AI system, unverified adoption of erroneous AI outputs, or inputting business secrets into an external AI system - the employer is liable under § 278 BGB for the fault of its employees as vicarious agents. Article 4 AI Act reinforces an existing duty of care and effectively becomes the benchmark against which the appropriateness of the organizational measures taken is assessed. If there is a complete lack of a traceable training and governance structure, the assumption of a breach of duty of care is likely.

3. Recourse Against Employees

Conversely, a company that suffers damage can seek recourse from responsible employees under the principles of internal damage compensation. Here, an interesting interaction emerges: in cases of slight negligence, the employee is typically not liable; in cases of moderate negligence, only partially; full liability generally only arises in cases of gross negligence or intent. Literature suggests that the success of a recourse claim may depend on whether the employer has fulfilled its training obligation under Article 4 AI Act. A company without a robust training concept may find itself at a disadvantage in a serious case - even with potentially gross negligence on the part of employees.

4. Liability of Management and Board

Finally, the question also concerns the management level itself. Managing directors of a GmbH (§ 43 Abs. 1 GmbHG) and board members of an AG (§§ 76, 93 Abs. 1 AktG) are obliged to take the necessary organizational measures to ensure compliance with legal behavior within the company - such as through a compliance management system that also incorporates the AI literacy obligation. If they violate this obligation culpably and the company suffers damage as a result, internal liability under § 43 Abs. 2 GmbHG or § 93 Abs. 2 S. 1 AktG may apply. The recognized business judgment rule in German law provides only limited assistance here: whether or not to establish a compliance system with a training concept is not a matter of entrepreneurial discretion but is legally mandated. Entrepreneurial discretion exists only regarding the specific design - as long as an appropriate minimum standard is maintained.

Interim Conclusion: While Article 4 AI Act is not subject to fines, it is by no means without consequences. The actual "sanctioning" occurs through the backdoor of general liability law - and this makes the norm more relevant for business practice than the absence of a fine might initially suggest.

 

IV. Looking Beyond the Obligation: Added Value in Practice

While the legal discussion of liability risks is certainly justified, our consulting practice with numerous in-house training sessions and workshops on AI literacy reveals another often underestimated effect: the real value does not arise only in disputes but already in the training room itself. In almost every format we have facilitated, most of the staff's open questions - from responsibility for AI outputs to handling confidential data and copyright issues - could be clarified through direct exchange.

Practical uncertainties in daily interactions with AI tools can often be resolved easily before they become actual problems. Moreover, through shared exchange, a collective awareness within the company is created. AI literacy is then not perceived as an abstract compliance requirement but as a jointly developed standard that the staff supports.

 

V. Conclusion and Outlook

The Digital Omnibus on AI has made Article 4 AI Act more practical without abandoning the obligation itself. The absence of a fine does not change the fact that deficiencies in AI literacy can become relevant under general civil, labor, and corporate law - for the company, for employees in recourse cases, and for the management level alike. Those who take this framework seriously and simultaneously leverage the practical value of training and workshops not only create legal certainty but also foster a sense of shared sovereignty in dealing with AI within the company.

 

SKW Schwarz is happy to assist you in designing suitable training programs and accompanying you in conducting initial workshops on AI literacy in your company. Please feel free to contact us so that we can jointly create the greatest possible value for your business.

09/07/2026, Marius Drabiniok, Dr. Oliver Hornung

Beyond EU Borders: What the Kodak/Fujifilm Decision Means for UPC Patent Litigation

Under certain conditions, the Unified Patent Court (UPC) can also rule on claims concerning the UK part of a classic European patent. This was clarified by the UPC Court of Appeal in its decision of 2 June 2026 in the Kodak/Fujifilm case (UPC_CoA_312/2025).

Following Brexit, the United Kingdom does not participate in the UPC. The UPC therefore has no jurisdiction over purely national UK patents. The situation can be different for the UK part of a classic European patent: Where the UPC has international jurisdiction over the defendant, in particular because the defendant is domiciled in a UPC Contracting Member State, the UPC may, according to the case law in Fujifilm v Kodak, also rule on alleged acts of infringement in the United Kingdom.

The Court of Appeal thus confirms the practical significance of the UPC’s so-called “long-arm jurisdiction”. This may offer considerable advantages for patent proprietors, as cross-border infringement claims can potentially be consolidated before a single court rather than pursued in parallel proceedings across multiple jurisdictions. This can streamline litigation, reduce costs and minimise the risk of conflicting decisions.

At the same time, relying on the UPC’s long-arm jurisdiction requires careful analysis and preparation. International jurisdiction merely provides access to the Court; it does not relieve the patent proprietor of the need to establish both infringement and the individual defendant’s responsibility for the alleged infringing acts. This is precisely where Fujifilm’s case ultimately failed. The Court of Appeal set aside the first-instance decision. In Germany, Kodak was able to rely on a right of prior use. As regards the United Kingdom, Fujifilm had failed to establish that the German Kodak entities named as defendants had themselves committed relevant acts of infringement in the UK or could be held legally responsible for acts committed by a UK group company. The Court’s assessment turned on the specific supply chain, ownership structure and economic control over the products. The mere fact that a German group company manufactured products for a UK company was not sufficient to attribute the latter’s importation or distribution activities in the UK to the German entity.

At the same time, the assessment remains challenging and requires particularly careful preparation: International jurisdiction merely provides access to the court. It neither dispenses with the need to establish patent infringement nor with the requirement to attribute the alleged acts to the specific defendant entity. This was precisely where Fujifilm failed in the case at hand. The Court of Appeal set aside the first-instance decision. In Germany, Kodak was able to rely on a right of prior use. With regard to the United Kingdom, however, it had not been sufficiently established that the German Kodak companies being sued had themselves carried out relevant acts of infringement there or that they were legally liable for such acts by a UK group company. The decisive factors were the specific supply chain, ownership structures and the economic control over the products. The mere fact that a German group company manufactured products for a UK company was not sufficient to hold the German entity responsible for the UK company’s subsequent import and distribution activities in the United Kingdom.

The decision therefore does not provide a carte blanche for cross-border litigation before the UPC. It does, however, demonstrate that, when dealing with classic European patents, companies should not shape their patent and litigation strategies solely around the territorial boundaries of the UPC Contracting Member States.

For defendants, intra-group manufacturing and distribution structures may offer potential lines of defence. For each market concerned, the patent proprietor must specifically plead and prove which group entity is responsible for the relevant acts of infringement; mere membership of the same corporate group is not sufficient. Companies facing infringement claims should therefore ensure that their manufacturing locations, supply chains and contractual arrangements, transfers of title, as well as the entities exercising actual decision-making authority and control over distribution, are clearly documented from an early stage.

Fujifilm v Kodak thus confirms that the UPC’s reach may extend beyond UPC Contracting Member States. Whether a cross-border infringement claim ultimately succeeds, however, will depend on the specific acts of infringement at issue and, crucially, on whether those acts can be attributed to the individual defendant.

 

09/01/2026, Margret Knitter

SKW Schwarz is advising the MM Group on the acquisition of the recycled cardboard plant from the R.D.M. Group

SKW Schwarz advised Mayr-Melnhof Karton AG (MM Group) on the acquisition of the business operations of the recycling cartonboard mill in Arnsberg from the R.D.M. Group. Through the transaction, structured as an asset deal, the MM Group is investing in its core business and expanding its production network. The Arnsberg mill is one of the established production sites for recycled cartonboard in Europe.

The closing of the transaction is still subject to regulatory approval under competition law. The acquisition is expected to be completed by the end of the year.

Based in Vienna, the MM Group is a leading provider of fiber-based packaging solutions, with a focus on recycling and sustainability. The listed company employs around 13,000 people at 60 sites across three continents.

Headquartered in Milan, the R.D.M. Group is a leading European manufacturer of cartonboard for packaging.

Advisers to MM Group:
SKW Schwarz, Munich: Dr. Stephan Morsch (lead), Marion Anzinger, Dr. Thomas Hausbeck, Dr. Angela Poschenrieder (Associated Partner; all Corporate/M&A), Michael Wahl, Sabrina Hochbrückner (Counsel; both Employment Law, Frankfurt), Dr. Klaus Jankowski (Public Law/Real Estate), Maria Rothämel (Counsel; Public Law; both Berlin); Associate: Christine Wärl (Corporate/M&A)

08/27/2026, Dr. Stephan Morsch, Marion Anzinger, Dr. Thomas Hausbeck, Dr. Angela Poschenrieder, Michael Wahl, Sabrina Hochbrückner, Dr. Klaus Jankowski, Maria Rothämel, Christine Wärl

SKW Schwarz advises OverDrive Europe on the acquisition of divibib

SKW Schwarz has advised OverDrive Europe GmbH, the European subsidiary of the leading U.S. digital library platform OverDrive,Inc., on the acquisition of divibib GmbH, the company behind the German digital lending service Onleihe, from ekz.bibliotheksservice GmbH.

Onleihe will be gradually migrated to the Libbyplatform, bringing together the digital catalogs of OverDrive and divibib for libraries and patrons across the DACH region. All other divisions of the ekz Group will not be affected by the transaction.

The acquisition deepens OverDrive’s commitment to libraries and readers in the DACH region.

OverDrive, Inc. is the company behind Libby, Sora, and Kanopy, the leading digital reading, learning, and entertainment apps for libraries and schools. OverDrive serves more than 600 public libraries, schools, and academic partners across Germany, Austria, and Switzerland.

divibib, a subsidiary of ekz.bibliotheksservice based in Reutlingen, has been operating the digital lending platform Onleihe since 2007, serving public libraries across Germany, Austria, Switzerland, and other European markets. ekz Group is a long-standing provider of services and technology for public libraries in the German-speaking countries.

The SKW Schwarz team advising OverDrive was led by Stephan Morsch (Corporate/M&A) and Stefan Peintinger (IT & Digital Business/IP), and included partner Alexander Möller (Employment), associated partner Matthias Pajunk (Procurement), counsel Eva Bonacker (Corporate/M&A), as well as associates Christine Wärl (Corporate/M&A) and Tamara Ulm (Employment).

08/21/2026, Dr. Stephan Morsch, Dr. Stefan Peintinger, Alexander Möller, Dr. Mathias Pajunk, Eva Bonacker, Christine Wärl, Tamara Ulm

Events

30

Focus topics

22

Expertise

30

Mixed

30

Further insights

Explore the latest legal developments, insights, publications and news from our firm.

No entries available at the moment.